[domestic law enforcement authorities] are related to more than one country.’3 Another, from West Africa, stated
that most of the victims targeted by cybercrime perpetrators within its territory were located ‘outside
of national boundaries.’4 Other countries said that most reported offences were ‘initiated outside’ of their
territory. Still others observed that ‘in most cases we act as a conduit.’5 Countries noted that the use of
proxy servers, and the growing influence of social media, were among the factors behind an
increasing number of cases involving a transnational dimension.6 One country even reported that
perpetrators are fully aware of jurisdictional issues and purposefully use internet resources, such as
mail servers, located abroad in an attempt to hide evidence of their illegal activities.7 The perception
is not uniform however. One country from South America reported that a considerable number of
reported transnational cases were ‘of domestic origin.’8
This Chapter examines jurisdictional and international cooperation approaches to
combating cybercrime – both at the level of international and regional cybercrime instruments, as
well as in the law and practice of states. It places information obtained from the Study questionnaire
within the international legal framework of sovereignty, jurisdiction, and international cooperation in
criminal matters.
The starting point - sovereignty and jurisdiction
The starting point for state jurisdiction and international cooperation is sovereignty. The
sovereign equality of states is protected by rules of customary public international law. These include
the obligation on states not to ‘interfere in any form or for any reason whatsoever in the internal and external
affairs of other States.’9
Law enforcement and criminal justice matters fall within this exclusive domain of the
sovereign state – with the result that, traditionally, criminal jurisdiction has been linked to geographical
territory. States must therefore refrain from bringing pressure to bear on other states regarding the
behaviour of specific national bodies, such as law enforcement agencies or the judiciary.10 Persons
may not be arrested, a summons may not be served, and police or tax investigations may not be
mounted on the territory of another state, except under the terms of a treaty or other consent
given.11
Of course, not all crimes occur neatly within the territorial jurisdiction. Where this is the
case, international law has come to recognize a number of bases of extra-territorial jurisdiction in
criminal matters.12 Common bases found in national law and international agreements are
summarized in the table below. Common to all of these principles is a broad sense of requirement
that a ‘sufficient connection’ or ‘genuine link’ between the offence and the state exercising
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q83.
Ibid.
Ibid.
Ibid.
Ibid.
Ibid.
As such, states have a right to sovereignty and territorial integrity, and to freely determine their own political, economic, cultural
and social system, including all matters essentially within their domestic jurisdiction. See Declaration on the Inadmissibility of
Intervention in the Domestic Affairs of States, annex to GA resolution A/RES/20/2131 (XX), 21 December 1965. Please also
refer to the Corfu Channel case, ICJ Reports 1949, 35, the Military and Paramilitary Activities case, ICJ Reports 1986, 202, and the
Nicaragua case, ICJ Reports 1986, 14, 109-10.
Even, for example, where nationals of one state are on trial overseas, the basic underlying principle is that the state cannot interfere
in the judicial procedures of the other sovereign state on behalf of its national. Similarly, states cannot take measures on the
territory of another state by way of enforcement of their own national laws without the consent of the latter. See Cassese, A.,
International Law. p.53.
Brownlie, I., 2003. Principles of Public International Law. 6th ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press. p.306.
Jeschek, H. H., Weigend, T., 1996. Lehrbuch des Strafrechts. Allgemeiner Teil. 5th edn. Berlin: Duncker & Humbold. pp.167 et seq.
184
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents