Jurisdiction provisions in international and regional cybercrime instruments
League of Arab
States Convention
Shanghai
Cooperation
Organization
Agreement
COMESA Draft
Model Bill
Commonwealth
Model Law
ITU/CARICOM/
CTU Model
Legislative Texts
Non-binding instruments
Council of Europe
Cybercrime
Convention
Territory-based jurisdiction
Territorial
─
Directed against
computer
─
system/data in
territory
Ships/Aircrafts
─
Nationality-based jurisdiction
Active
─
Passive
─
Other jurisdiction
Habitual Residence
─
State interests
─
When extradition
─
refused
Additional provisions
Rules on concurrent
─
jurisdiction
Commonwealth of
Independent States
Agreement
Grounds for
Jurisdiction
Draft African
Union Convention
Binding instruments
─
■
■
─
■
■
■
─
─
─
─
■
─
─
─
■
■
─
■
■
■
─
─
■
─
■
─
─
─
■
─
■
─
■
─
─
─
─
─
─
■
─
─
─
─
─
─
─
─
─
■
■
─
■
─
─
─
■
■
─
■
─
─
The details of individual provisions are examined below, together with relevant examples
and practices from information reported by countries through the Study cybercrime questionnaire.
Prosecuting extra-territorial offences
During information gathering for the Study, countries were asked about the perceived
sufficiency of their national legal frameworks for the criminalization and prosecution of cybercrime
acts committed outside of their country.47 Figure 7.2 shows that the general picture is one of a
reasonable degree of sufficiency, but
Figure 7.2: Does national law provide a sufficient framework for
with marked regional differences.
criminalization and prosecution of cybercrime acts committed
Around one-third of total responding
outside of country?
countries perceived their national
Yes
Europe (n=15)
legal framework for extra-territorial
In Part
offences to be ‘sufficient.’ A further
No
Asia & Oceania (n=19)
40 per cent considered it to be
sufficient ‘in part.’ Twenty-five per
cent reported that it was ‘not
Americas (n=12)
Frameworks
were
sufficient.’48
perceived to be least sufficient in the
Africa (n=9)
Americas, where only 40 per cent of
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
countries reported that their legal
Source:
Study
cybercrime
questionnaire.
Q19.
(n=55)
frameworks were sufficient or partly
47
48
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q19.
Ibid.
190
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents