CHAPTER SEVEN: INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION Jurisdictional conflicts International and regional instruments – Operation of the range of jurisdictional bases by different countries can lead to the situation where more than one country asserts jurisdiction over a particular cybercrime act. A number of the international and regional instruments address this ‘concurrent’ jurisdiction challenge. Some specify, for example, that where an offence falls within the jurisdiction of more than one state and when any of the states concerned can validly prosecute on the basis of the facts, states must ‘cooperate’ or ‘consult’ in order to decide the most appropriate jurisdiction for prosecution.81 The European instruments, in particular, aim at ‘centralising proceedings in a single [state].’82 The League of Arab States Convention provides a detailed order of priority for competing jurisdictional claims as follows: (i) states whose security or interests have been disrupted by the offence; (ii) states in whose territory the offence was committed; and (iii) the state of nationality of the offender. If no balance can be found according to this order, then priority is accorded to the first requesting state. 83 National approaches – During information gathering for the Study, countries reported that, in general, they did not have specific legislation intended to resolve conflicts of jurisdiction in cybercrime cases.84 Nonetheless, a number of countries mentioned plans to address possible conflicts of jurisdiction in cyber-specific legislation by means of legal surveys or policy positions. One country, however, noted that, as far as transnational cybercrime was concerned ‘the range of possible cases and scenarios may make it difficult, and possibly inadvisable, to develop concrete universal legal rules based on jurisdictional exclusivity.’85 Countries reported resolving jurisdictional disputes by relying on formal and informal consultations with other countries in order to avoid double-investigations and jurisdictional conflicts.86 As one country in Europe noted, ‘[m]ost of the time such conflicts of jurisdiction can be avoided through informal prior consultation, or spontaneous exchange of information. Also joint investigation operations can contribute […].’87 Communication is conducted bilaterally, or through channels made available by institutions such as INTERPOL, Europol and Eurojust.88 One country from the Americas indicated that, since the prosecution of these fragmented crimes was highly difficult, proceedings would essentially only be initiated when there was a strong indication that either the offender or the victim was one of its citizens. All other cases would be communicated to the countries of origin via INTERPOL channels.89 In addition, a number of countries referred to the principle of ne bis in idem (‘not twice’), and will only initiate proceedings if none are conducted in the country where the acts were committed. Before giving up their claim on jurisdiction, some countries require assurances that the other state claiming jurisdiction will adhere to human rights standards during investigations and proceedings.90 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 Council of Europe Child Protection Convention, Art. 25(8); Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention, Art. 22(5); EU Decision on Attacks against Information Systems, Art. 10(4); and COMESA Draft Model Bill, Art. 40(e). See, for example, EU Decision on Attacks against Information Systems, Art. 10(4). League of Arab States Convention, Art. 30(3). Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q18. Ibid. Ibid. Ibid. Ibid. Ibid. Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q19. 195

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents