CHAPTER SEVEN: INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION
7.3 International cooperation I – formal cooperation
Key results:
Due to the volatile nature of electronic evidence, international cooperation in
cybercrime matters requires timely response and the ability to request specialized
investigative actions
Use of traditional forms of international cooperation predominates for obtaining
extra-territorial evidence in cybercrime cases. Over 70 per cent of responding
countries reported using formal mutual legal assistance requests for this purpose
Within such formal cooperation, almost 60 per cent of requests use bilateral
instruments as the legal basis. Multilateral instruments are used in around 20 per
cent of cases
Response times for formal mechanisms are reported to be of the order of months,
for both extradition and mutual legal assistance requests
Urgent channels for mutual legal assistance requests do exist in some countries,
however the impact of these on response times is unclear
The current international cooperation picture risks the emergence of country
clusters that have the necessary powers and procedures to cooperate amongst
themselves, but are restricted, for all other countries, to ‘traditional’ modes of
international cooperation that may take no account of the specificities of electronic
evidence
This section examines mechanisms of international cooperation in cybercrime matters
found in international instruments, and in national law and practice.
Cooperation provisions in international and regional instruments
As discussed in Chapter Three (Legislation and frameworks) of this Study, a number of
international and regional cybercrime instruments contain international cooperation provisions.
Instruments typically either contain broad general obligations on States parties to cooperate,92
and/or particular cooperation mechanisms, including extradition93 and mutual legal assistance.94 The
table below summarizes international cooperation provisions in key binding and non-binding
international and regional cybercrime instruments. Further details and article numbers are also
included in the table at Annex Three to this Study.
92
93
94
Commonwealth of Independent States Agreement, Art. 5; Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention, Art. 23; Shanghai
Cooperation Organization Agreement, Art. 3-5. The Draft African Union Convention refers to the principle in Art. III(14).
COMESA Draft Model Bill, Art. 42(c); Council of Europe Child Protection Convention, Art. 38(3); EU Decision on Fraud and
Counterfeiting, Art. 10.
Commonwealth of Independent States Agreement, Art. 6; Council of Europe Child Protection Convention, Arts. 25, 27;
ECOWAS Draft Directive, Art. 35; League of Arab States Convention, Arts. 32, 34.
197
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents