CHAPTER SEVEN: INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION
Instrument
Draft African Union
Convention
Commonwealth of Independent
States Agreement
Scope of international cooperation provisions
‘Cybercrime’
‘Offences relating to computer information’
‘Criminal offences related to computer systems and
data’
‘Collection of evidence in electronic form of a criminal
offence’
Council of Europe Cybercrime
Convention
League of Arab States
Convention
‘Information and information technology offences’
‘Gathering of electronic evidence in offences’
Shanghai Cooperation
Organization Agreement
‘International information security’
Cooperation mechanisms contained within international and regional cybercrime
instruments must also be placed in the wider international cooperation context. While a number of
the instruments can be relied upon as a legal basis for specific cooperation acts,95 it must be
remembered that States parties to the instruments are also party to broader networks of multilateral
and bilateral agreements relating to cooperation in criminal matters – including treaties such as the
Organized Crime Convention. Depending upon the nature of the act under investigation, it is
possible that cooperation needs can fall within a range of legal mechanisms. Some of the cybercrime
instruments recognize this point. The Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention for example
provides that parties shall co-operate with each other, not only ‘in accordance with the provisions of this
chapter’ but also ‘through the application of relevant international instruments on international co-operation in
criminal matters, arrangements agreed on the basis of uniform or reciprocal legislation, and domestic laws.’96
Finally, it is important to emphasize that non-binding instruments cannot provide the same
international legal basis for cooperation as binding instruments. While the COMESA Draft Model
Bill, for example, specifies that ‘the legal authorities of [this country] shall cooperate directly and to the widest
extent possible with legal authorities of another country,’97 this constitutes only a recommended provision to
be included in national law. Even where such a provision is incorporated, countries generally still
require a politico-legal mechanism for specific acts of cooperation – whether a multilateral or bilateral
treaty, or an understanding of reciprocity – with the particular requesting country. In this respect,
however, the existence in some countries of ‘open-door’ cooperation policies, under which national
law enables cooperation, in principle, with any country, should also be noted.98
Extradition and mutual legal assistance in international and regional instruments
Two binding instruments included in the table above (the Council of Europe Cybercrime
Convention and the League of Arab States Convention), and one non-binding instrument (the
COMESA Draft Model Bill), specifically envisage extradition for offences contained therein.99 All
of these make extradition dependent upon dual criminality and seriousness of the offence. Three
binding instruments (the Commonwealth of Independent States Agreement, the Council of Europe
95
96
97
98
99
See, for example, Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention, Arts. 24 et. seq.; League of Arab States Convention, Arts. 31 et seq.;
Commonwealth of Independent States Agreement, Arts. 6 et seq.; COMESA Draft Model Bill, Arts. 42 et seq.
Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention, Art. 24.
COMESA Draft Model Bill, Art.41.
A few responding countries noted the existence of such policies (Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q220).
Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention, Art. 24; League of Arab States Convention, Art. 31; COMESA Draft Model Bill, Art.
42(c).
199
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents