CHAPTER SEVEN: INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION
cooperation matters may, for example, be handled under national mechanisms such as executive
orders, or administrative policies.
The use of formal cooperation
mechanisms
in
transnational
cybercrime cases is predominant over
other forms of cooperation. Figure
7.4 shows that over 70 per cent of law
enforcement authorities reported that
formal mutual legal assistance was
most often used to obtain a range of
evidence
types
from
other
111
Less-used
jurisdictions.
mechanisms were reported to include
informal police cooperation, direct
contact with a service provider, and
the use of 24/7 contact points.112
Figure 7.4: Means of obtaining extra‐territorial evidence
6%
4%
Formal MLA request
Informal police cooperation
8%
Direct contact with service
provider
24/7 network point of
contact
9%
Other
73%
Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q105. (n=56, r=221)
Within such formal cooperation, the use of bilateral instruments for cybercrime cases is most
common. Almost 60 per cent of countries reported that they rely on bilateral instruments as the
legal basis for extradition and mutual legal assistance in cybercrime cases.113 A further 20 per cent
cited reciprocity as the basis. Despite the fact that around 60 per cent of countries that responded to
the Study questionnaire have signed or ratified an international or regional cybercrime agreement
containing cooperation provisions,114 only in 25 per cent of cases were international and regional
instruments cited as the legal basis.115
The number of countries
that responded to the question on
Figure 7.5: Legal basis of cybercrime extradition and MLA requests
the legal basis for cooperation is
1%
comparatively low. Results should
Multilateral instrument
18%
19%
therefore be interpreted with
Regional instrument
caution.
Nonetheless,
the
Bilateral instrument
Reciprocity
predominant use of bilateral
5%
Other
instruments and reciprocity reflects
both: (i) the fact that not all
countries are party to multilateral
57%
instruments; and (ii) use of
‘traditional’ modes of international
cooperation, even where countries
are party to multilateral instruments.
Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q202‐207 and Q227‐232. (n=21, r=50)
In this respect, no country reported
the existence of cyber-specific
bilateral instruments, and none were identified in the course of research for the Study.
111
112
113
114
115
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q105.
Ibid.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q202-207 and Q227-232. The proportion of countries responding to these particular questions
that had signed or ratified an international or regional cybercrime instrument was the same as for all responding countries.
Signatories or States Parties to the Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention (40 per cent), the League of Arab States Convention
(10 per cent), the Commonwealth of Independent States Agreement (15 per cent), and the Shanghai Cooperation Organization
Agreement (10 per cent). Numbers sum to more than 60 per cent due to multiple instrument membership for some countries.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q202-207 and Q227-Q232.
201
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents