were not party to any multilateral cybercrime instrument did not have channels for urgent requests, compared with 40 per cent of countries that were party to a multilateral cybercrime instrument.166 Figure 7.9: Channels for urgent MLA requests Europe (n=15) Asia & Oceania (n=10) Americas (n=8) Yes No Africa The reported use of (n=4) expedited means for cybercrime 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% mutual legal assistance requests goes Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q222. (n=37) some way towards addressing challenges of electronic evidence volatility. However, only half of total responding countries reported use of such mechanisms. In addition, if overall formal assistance response times reported through the Study questionnaire include requests handled on an ‘urgent’ basis, then average response times – and indeed the predominate distribution of response times – is still measured in the order of months, as opposed to days. As discussed below, the situation is different in respect of informal modes of cooperation. While informal cooperation offers a more limited range of assistance, response times are typically faster. 7.4 International cooperation II – informal cooperation Key results:  Modes of informal cooperation are possible for around two-thirds of reporting countries, although few countries have a policy for the use of such mechanisms  A number of informal cooperation networks in the area of cybercrime exist, including the G8 and Council of Europe ‘24/7’ networks  Initiatives for informal cooperation and for facilitating formal cooperation, such as 24/7 networks, offer important potential for faster response times, of the order of days  Such initiatives may, however, be under-utilized. The number of cases handled by 24/7 networks reported by responding countries represented around 3 per cent of the total number of cybercrime cases encountered by law enforcement for that group of countries  Analysis of formal and informal cooperation mechanisms is unable to find that the current global cooperation situation is sufficient. Globally, divergences in the scope of cooperation provisions in multilateral and bilateral instruments; a lack of response time obligation; multiple informal law enforcement networks; and variance in cooperation safeguards represent significant challenges to effective international cooperation regarding electronic evidence in criminal matters International and regional perspectives In addition to forms of formal international cooperation, steps in the process of extraterritorial law enforcement investigations may be undertaken by informal police-to-police or agencyto-agency communication. Such communication can be used prior to a formal mutual legal assistance 166 Ibid. 208

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents