24/7 network – many cases may be successfully investigated at the national level alone. Nonetheless,
the group of countries that provided data on use of 24/7 contact points also stated that, on average,
60 per cent of cases involved a transnational dimension.202 As such, there may be significant scope
for more extensive use of the mechanism.
% of requests
Underutilization of 24/7 Figure 7.16: Average time for response to requests sent and
networks risks losing potential received by focal point for cooperation in cybercrime cases
35%
32%
gains in request response time.
30%
Countries responding to the Study
questionnaire reported that almost
23%
25%
90 per cent of requests handled by
19%
20%
24/7 contact points received a
15%
13%
13%
response within one month.203
10%
Over 20 per cent of requests
received a response within one to
5%
two days. A faster response time
0%
for 24/7 requests than for mutual
1‐2
2‐5
5‐10
10‐30
>30
Number of days
legal assistance requests can be
Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q107. (n=25, r=47)
expected, not only due to the
‘24/7’ nature of the system, but
also due to the fact that – as a form of informal cooperation – the range of actions that can be carried
out by a 24/7 contact point is more limited than that in formal mutual legal assistance.
As such, the ‘response time’ measured corresponds to a different set of assistance actions
than those offered through mutual legal assistance – and the two ‘response time’ figures are not
directly comparable. As discussed above, an informal mechanism, such as a 24/7 contact point, is
more likely to provide general technical and legal advice and to facilitate more formal actions, than it
is to undertake evidence gathering itself.204 Nonetheless, the fact that 24/7 contact points often
deliver a response within a matter of days represents an important opening of communication
channels for the facilitation of more timely cooperation, including – potentially – actions that require
a more formal request.
Sufficient cooperation?
This Chapter earlier found that current bases of jurisdiction likely are sufficient for avoiding
jurisdictional gaps in the investigation and combating of cybercrime acts. The analysis of formal and
informal cooperation mechanisms, on the other hand, is unable to find that the current global
situation is sufficient for meeting cybercrime investigative and prosecutorial challenges.
While a number of options exist – including the use of informal cooperation, either directly
or to facilitate formal cooperation – over 70 per cent of countries reported most often using formal
mutual legal assistance requests to obtain electronic evidence located in another jurisdiction. Within
formal mutual legal assistance, bilateral instruments dominate – drawing on traditional
communication methods such as post and diplomatic letters and resulting in average response times
of the order of months rather than days. As mentioned by countries, long cooperation response
times create significant challenges due to the volatility of electronic evidence.
202
203
204
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q83. Data only for countries that also responded to Q107.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q107.
See above, Section 7.4 International cooperation II – informal cooperation, National approaches to informal cooperation.
214
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents