CHAPTER SEVEN: INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION
While many countries engage in informal cooperation in cybercrime cases on a faster time
scale, the range of investigative actions that can be provided varies considerably, as well as the
existence or not of clear policies on its use. Many countries acknowledge that evidence obtained
through informal cooperation cannot be considered for sustainable supply of evidence at trial. Due
perhaps to the diversity of approaches, informal cooperation might even be considered, in some
cases, to be a cumbersome mechanism.205 While ‘24/7’ networks hold promise for streamlining
informal cooperation and facilitating formal cooperation, they tend to be used comparatively
infrequently when compared with the potential pool of transnational cybercrime cases that come to
the attention of law enforcement authorities.
Many such challenges arise from differing membership of international and regional
instruments. This can be seen in areas such as differences in the availability of urgent mutual legal
assistance channels, and the ability to offer specialized measures, such as preservation of data, in
response to cooperation requests. The current international cooperation picture risks the
emergence of country clusters that have the necessary powers and procedures to cooperate
amongst themselves, but are restricted, for all other countries, to ‘traditional’ modes of
international cooperation that take no account of the specificities of electronic evidence. This
is particularly the case for cooperation in investigative actions. A lack of common approach,
including within current multilateral cybercrime instruments, means that requests for actions,
such as expedited preservation of data outside of those countries with international obligations
to ensure such a facility and to make it available upon request, may not be easily fulfilled. The
inclusion of this power in the draft African Union Cybersecurity Convention may go some
way towards closing this lacuna. Globally, divergences in the scope of cooperation provisions
in multilateral and bilateral instruments; a lack of response time obligation; multiple informal
law enforcement networks; and variance in cooperation safeguards, represent significant
challenges to effective international cooperation regarding electronic evidence in criminal
matters.
205
Response from regional expert nominated by WEOG to preliminary results from the Study.
215
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents