7.5 Extra-territorial evidence from clouds and service providers
Key results:
Due to developments in cloud computing, data ‘location,’ while technically
knowable, is becoming increasingly artificial, to the extent that traditional mutual
legal assistance requests will often be addressed to the country that is the seat of the
service provider, rather than the country where the data is physically located
Through use of a live connection from a suspect’s device, or through use of access
credentials, investigators increasingly – knowingly or unknowingly – access extraterritorial data during evidence gathering, without the consent of the country where
the data is physically situated
Investigators may also occasionally obtain data from extra-territorial service
providers through informal direct requests, although service providers more usually
require due legal process
Relevant existing provisions on ‘trans-border’ access found in the Council of Europe
Cybercrime Convention and the League of Arab States Convention on Information
Technology Offences do not adequately cover such situations – due to a focus on
the ‘consent’ of the person having lawful authority to disclose the data, and
presumed knowledge of the location of the data at the time of access or receipt
Such challenges require: (i) (re)-conceptualization of the extent to which ‘data location’
can still be used as a guiding principle; and (ii) the development of common standards and
safeguards concerning the circumstances, if any, under which direct access to extraterritorial data may be conducted by law enforcement
The challenge
As this Chapter has shown, current methods of international cooperation in cybercrime
cases face significant challenges – including those of long response times for mutual legal assistance,
and non-uniformity of national investigative powers for obtaining computer data as evidence. A
third challenge – alluded to in the section on jurisdiction but not yet elaborated – is that of
identifying the relevant jurisdiction to which a cooperation request for the obtaining of electronic
evidence should be addressed in the first place. This challenge is becoming increasingly acute as
computer services move to geographically distributed servers and data centres, collectively known as
cloud computing.
Cloud computing services have been characterized as ‘infrastructure-as-a-service,’ ‘softwareas-a-service,’ and ‘platform-as-a-service,’ covering the provision of ‘virtual’ machines over the
internet, the provision of software applications, and the provision of a whole network, server
system, operating system and storage, respectively.206 In this sense, ‘the cloud’ is a new term for an
old idea – harnessing another organization’s infrastructure and expertise to deliver computing
resources as a service over the internet. The physical hardware behind cloud services is housed in
data centres located at strategic points designed to minimize delay in service delivery, as well as
electricity and equipment-cooling costs. Users of Google services, for example, may access data
206
See, for example, European Parliament Directorate General for Internal Polices, Citizens’ Rights and Constitutional Affairs, 2012.
Fighting cybercrime and protecting privacy in the cloud.
216
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents