CHAPTER SEVEN: INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION stored or processed in North America, South Eastern Asia, or Northern or Western Europe.207 It is frequently claimed that it cannot be known where in the cloud data is stored, and that data can be fragmented across multiple locations. It is certainly correct that databases can be hosted across multiple data centres, including in different countries, and containing multiple copies of the same data.208 This may involve automated dynamic data placement across data centres physically located in different countries.209 It is also true that contractual agreements between cloud service providers and users do not always divulge data centre location, or contain representations or conditions regarding the geographical location of where data will be held.210 On the other hand, some cloud providers enable users to designate the physical region in which their data and servers will be located, and undertake not to move content from the selected region without notifying the customer.211 In addition, geo-proof protocols are well under development for the remote identification of data source origin – enabling independent verification of the geo-location of data in the cloud.212 Overall, increasing compliance requirements, customer demands, and data management technology are trending towards accurate cloud data location. Nonetheless, it remains the case that – even when cloud data is geo-identified – it will reveal a pattern of dispersed, sometimes transient, data, including with copies in multiple jurisdictions. Where cloud data is evidence in a cybercrime investigation, it may well be ‘extra-territorial’ (in multiple countries) with respect to the investigating country. In many cases, however, even the basic fact of extra-territoriality may not be known for certain by law enforcement investigators.213 Often, the starting point is merely the name of the cloud service provider – such as Amazon or Google. While the technical possibility may exist, it is extremely unlikely that a law enforcement investigator can know – at the outset of an investigation – in which country the cloud data is physically located (even given that it has not already been moved). If the investigating country is not the seat of the cloud service provider, a ‘traditional’ mutual legal assistance approach would require a communication to the central authority of the cloud provider’s home jurisdiction, with a request for preservation and/or production of the computer data. It is notable that under this approach, the mutual legal assistance request may not even be sent to the county in which the data actually resides. Facebook, for example, hosts the data of many users in a data centre in one country in Northern Europe,214 but specifies that it discloses records in accordance with applicable laws cited from a country in North America.215 For foreign law enforcement, Facebook guidelines indicate that a mutual legal assistance request or letter rogatory directed to the country in North America may be required to compel the disclosure of the contents 207 208 209 210 211 212 213 214 215 See http://www.google.com/about/datacenters/inside/locations/index.html See, for example, http://www.datastax.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/09/WP-DataStax-MultiDC.pdf , referring to use of multidata centre operations control across ‘multiple geo-zones’ by, amongst others, eBay and Netflix. See, for example, Peterson, Z.N.J., Gondree, M., Beverly, R., 2011. A Position Paper on Data Sovereignty: The Importance of Geolocating Data in the Cloud. For an example of automated data placement technology across geo-distributed data centres, see Agarwal, S., et al., 2010. Volley: Automated Data Placement for Geo-Distributed Cloud Services. Benson, K., Dowsley, R., Shacham, H., 2011. Do you know where your cloud files are? Proceedings of the 3rd ACM Workshop on Cloud Computing Security, pp.73-82. See, for example, Amazon Web Services, 2012. Risk and Compliance. November 2012. Available at: http://media.amazonwebservices.com/AWS_Risk_and_Compliance_Whitepaper.pdf Ibid. Demonstrating successful identification of approximate geolocations of data in Amazon’s cloud. See also, Albeshri, A., Boyd, C. and Gonzalez Nieto, J., 2012. Geoproof: proofs of geographic location for cloud computing environment. Proceedings of the 32nd International Conference on Distributed Computing Systems Workshops 2012, IEEE, Macau, China, pp.506-514. Although it may, perhaps, be assumed based on a broad knowledge of cloud service provider data centre locations. See https://www.facebook.com/luleaDataCenter See http://www.facebook.com/safety/groups/law/guidelines/ 217

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents