CHAPTER SEVEN: INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION Cloud computing was certainly not as developed at the time of the drafting of Article 32 of the Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention. Nonetheless, the drafters specifically envisaged the application of Article 32(b) to, amongst others, the situation where ‘a person’s e-mail may be stored in another country by a service provider.’225 As such, Article 32(b) conceivably applies in wide range of circumstances, including accessing or receiving computer data from extra-territorial individuals; private sector organizations; service providers; and – in today’s world – cloud service operators. A potential advantage of Article 32(b) to law enforcement is that, if lawful and voluntary consent is contained, investigators do not have to follow mutual legal assistance procedures that move too slowly for capture of transient data. National practice Asia & Africa Americas Oceania Europe (n=8,6) (n=12,11) (n=15,14) (n=20,20) During information gathering for the Study, countries were asked about the use of ‘transborder access to a computer system or data’ as an investigative measure,226 and about whether ‘transborder access’ to a Figure 7.17: Police use of trans‐border access for investigation of computer system or data cybercrime and other crimes within the country by Yes foreign law enforcement Cybercrime No 227 was permitted. Non‐cybercrime Cybercrime With respect to use Non‐cybercrime of ‘trans-border’ access by Cybercrime law enforcement Non‐cybercrime authorities, around 20 per Cybercrime cent of countries in the Non‐cybercrime Americas, and Asia and 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Oceania reported that the Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q96. (n=55,51) measure was used, either for the investigation of cybercrime or other crimes. This rose to around 40 per cent of responding countries in Africa, and 50 per cent in Europe.228 The higher percentage in Europe may reflect the influence of Article 32(b) of the Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention. In responding to the questionnaire, however, countries placed a wide meaning on the term ‘trans-border’ access – with some countries including the situation where direct access to extraterritorial data was carried out, but only after approval had been received from the foreign authorities.229 A number of countries referred to particular restrictions on the practice, such as a need to obtain the consent of the owner, notifiction conditions, and a requirement to ensure that the data is actually stored abroad. Countries that did not make use of the practice frequently cited a lack of legal framework as the main reason for not doing so. Some countries highlighted in particular that they were constrained in gathering evidence abroad to the use of mutual legal assistance and letters rogatory.230 225 226 227 228 229 230 Concerning passive interception sites in one country monitoring wireless communications from a foreign country, see also, ECtHR. Application No. 54934/00. 29 June 2006, in which the Court found that the respondent country had not acted in a manner which interfered with the territorial sovereignty of foreign states as protected in public international law. Council of Europe, 2001. Explanatory Report to Convention on Cybercrime. Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q96. Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q108. Ibid. Ibid. Ibid. 219

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents