CHAPTER TWO: THE GLOBAL PICTURE
interception or acquisition of computer data; computer-related fraud; computer-related identity
offences; or sending or controlling sending of spam.39
Mapping C&Cs and zombies – As botnets facilitate a wide range of cybercrime acts, an
understanding of the location and extent of botnet C&Cs and zombies represents one important
approach to characterizing ‘global cybercrime.’ Estimates suggest that more than one million unique
IP addresses globally functioned at some point as a botnet C&C in 2011.40 The distribution of
identified C&Cs41 is
Figure 2.8: C&C servers, by country (2011)
shown in Figures
2.8 and 2.9 for the
years 2011 and
2012, per 100,000
country
IP
In
addresses.42
addition to a cluster
of
C&Cs
in
countries
in
Eastern
Europe,
numbers of C&Cs
are high relative to
Source: UNODC elaboration of data from Team Cymru.
the total number of
country
IP
Figure 2.9: C&C servers, by country (2012)
addresses
in
Western,
Central
and South-Eastern
Asia, as well as in
Central
America
and the Caribbean.
While the absolute
number of C&Cs is
high in countries in
North
America,
Western
Europe
and East Asia,
Source: UNODC elaboration of data from Team Cymru.
relative C&C rates
in these countries are low, due in part to the high number of internet connections and resultant IP
addresses. Conversely, a small number of C&Cs in a country with limited connectivity may create a
high C&C rate – in the same way as a few crimes on a small island can create a ‘high’ crime rate.
per 100,000 IP addresses
<10
10-50
50-100
100-250
250-500
>500
per 100,000 IP addresses
<10
10-50
50-100
100-250
250-500
>500
The global distribution of C&C servers is not necessarily linked with the location of
perpetrators, or bot ‘herders’, who control C&Cs and their bots for the purposes of profit. The
location of C&Cs servers can be moved often to avoid detection, and can include the use of
39
40
41
42
Ibid.
Estimate based on data from Team Cymru.
Data corresponds to IP addresses identified at any time during 2011 or 2012 as operating as an IRC (internet relay chat) or HTTP
(hypertext transfer protocol) C&C server.
Data from Team Cymru. C&C rates per country are plotted in green (2011) and purple (2012), together with geolocation of all
global IP addresses in blue (Data from MaxMind). Plotting identified C&Cs per 100,000 country IP addresses allows greater crossnational comparability than plotting of absolute C&C numbers. Geolocation of C&C IP addresses is subject to a number of
challenges including use of proxy connections. Nonetheless location at country level is generally considered acceptable.
33
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents