CHAPTER TWO: THE GLOBAL PICTURE
trade secrets. When these rights are infringed – such as by unlawful copying or use – the means of
enforcement usually lies in civil proceedings between individuals with, in certain cases, the right to
bring private criminal prosecutions. In addition, in some circumstances, the state may have the right
to initiate criminal proceedings. Generally, international agreements such as TRIPS specify that
countries shall provide for criminal procedures and penalties at least in cases that are ‘committed wilfully
and on a commercial scale.’63
Identifying the nature and extent of computer-related, or online, criminal intellectual
property right infringement is therefore far from simple. The best that can be done, on a global
scale, is to identify how much – and what type of – material likely infringes property rights overall.
Depending upon the context and circumstances – including scale, intent, purpose, and applicable
law and jurisdiction – a certain proportion of individuals involved in such infringing use may then be
subject to criminal sanctions.
Number of identified URLs (Thousands)
Thousands
Copyright – as the right protecting books, writings, music, films and computer programs –
has particular relevance to online content. Globally, some estimates suggest that almost 24 per cent of
total internet traffic infringes copyright.64 The level of infringing traffic varies by internet ‘venue,’
being highest in areas such as P2P services or ‘cyberlocker’ download sites, that are commonly used
for distribution of films, television episodes, music, computer games and software.65 Analysis of
requests concerning over 6.5 million URLs by copyright holders for removal of infringing content
from
Google
Figure 2.12: Copyright removal requests received by Google from top 60
services
gives
copyright owners, by content type and location of identified website 2011‐2012
some insight into
3,000
Eastern Asia
the distribution of
Southern Asia
2,500
the
type
of
Eastern Europe
material,
and
Northern Europe
2,000
Western Europe
location of the
Caribbean
66
hosting
site.
1,500
North America
Copyright holders
1,000
most
often
requested removal
500
of
infringing
music, followed
0
Music
Adult material
Film and
Software
Professional
Video and
Written word
by adult material,
broadcast
services
computer
film and broadcast
games
and
computer
Source: UNODC elaboration of Google Transparency Report
software. Other
forms of content were the object of a considerably lower number of requests. The majority of sites
hosting this material were located in North America and Europe, although the Caribbean also
featured for sites hosting infringing music.
While this information cannot be used to ascertain criminal intellectual property
infringement, it is notable that some individual removal requests concern multiple URLs, sometimes
63
64
65
66
TRIPS, Art. 61.
Envisional, 2011. Technical report: An Estimate of Infringing Use of the Internet. January 2011. This estimate excludes all pornography, the
infringing status of which can be difficult to discern.
Ibid.
The analysis is restricted to the top 60 requesting copyright holders by number of URLS requested for removal. Results from
removal requests received by Google are influenced both by the nature and extent of infringing material and the propensity of
rights holders to actively seek for infringing material and to request removal.
37
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents