CHAPTER TWO: THE GLOBAL PICTURE
exploit computer vulnerabilities and hijack large numbers of computers means that cybercrime
perpetrators no longer require high levels of technical skill.95 Skill levels are therefore likely to be
highly variable96 and – as discussed below – this may itself play some role in cybercrime group
structure. Overall, however, education levels amongst cybercrime perpetrators may still be higher
than for conventional, or all, crime. The Lu study found 28 per cent of cybercrime suspects in the
territory had undertaken tertiary education, compared with eight per cent for all crime. Similarly, the
HPP study found that more than half of hackers had undertaken tertiary education. Nonetheless, as
noted by the BAE Detica study, it is likely that the ‘artificial’ acquisition of technical skills (such as
through malware toolkits including ZeuS or the Butterfly Bot) has resulted in a shift away from the
traditional profile of a highly-skilled digital criminal, towards a much wider pool of individuals.
Child pornography perpetrators
The profile of persons engaged in the computer-related production, distribution or
possession of child pornography may be different to that of cybercrime perpetrators in general.
Recent information on this perpetrator group has been gathered by the ‘Virtual Global Taskforce’
(VGT)97 in the form of a small non-random sample of 103 persons arrested for downloading and
exchanging child pornography through online P2P services.98
Age and social status – All suspects in the VGT cohort were male and ranged in age from 15
to 73 years, with an average age of 41 years. One in five suspects was not working but was retired,
unemployed, or receiving health-related welfare benefits. The others were working or studying. 42
per cent were living with a partner and/or children. These perpetrators were significantly older
(average of 50 years) than single offenders (average of 35 years). All suspects were concerned with
hiding their activities from others, but 60 per cent succeeded in separating it completely from their
daily life. For the rest of the group, their offending activities tended to become obsessive, were more
or less enmeshed with their daily life, and possibly not well hidden from others. This latter group
tended to be of low socio-economic status and to be highly computer literate and around 4 per cent
of offenders reported a mental health problem.
Offending patterns – Suspects tended to have been involved in child pornography offending
for a comparatively long period – an average of five years, ranging from six months to 30 years.
Over 60 per cent of suspects not only collected child pornography but also traded/distributed it
through a P2P network, and 35 per cent were involved in network(s) other than P2P. Of those, half
participated in ‘offline’ networks – suggesting that individuals who go beyond accessing child
pornography to trading it do so not only online, but also offline.
Links with ‘offline’ offending – As between ‘online’ and ‘offline’ offenders, online offenders are
more likely to be Caucasian, unemployed and marginally younger than offline offenders.99 Links
nonetheless may exist.100 One recent meta-study found that in a sample of over 3,500 online child
95
96
97
98
99
100
See, for example, Symantec, 2011. Report on Attack Kits and Malicious Websites; Fortinet, 2013. Fortinet 2013 Cybercrime Report –
Cybercriminals Today Mirror Legitimate Business Processes; and Trend Micro, 2012. The Crimeware Evolution.
The HPP, for example, found that hacker technical skills were distributed as follows: low (21 per cent); medium (32 per cent); high
(22 per cent); expert (24 per cent).
The Virtual Global Taskforce For Combating Online Child Sexual Abuse is an international partnership between nine law
enforcement agencies established in 2003. See www.virtualglobaltaskforce.com
Because of the small size of the sample and its non-random case selection process, findings are not generalizable to the population
of online offenders. Nonetheless, some insights into the characteristics of these individuals and their offending can be gained. See
Bouhours, B. and Broadhurst, R., 2011. Statistical Report: Virtual Global Taskforce P2P Online Offender Sample July 2010–June 2011.
Canberra: Australian National University. Available at: SSRN: http://ssrn.com/abstract=2174815 or
http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2174815
Babchishin, K., Hanson, R. and Herrmann, C., 2011. The Characteristics of Online Sex Offenders: A Meta-Analysis. Sex Abuse: A
Journal of Research and Treatment, 23(1):92-123.
See for example, Broadhurst, R. and Jayawardena, K., 2007. Online Social Networking and Paedophilia: An Experimental Research
‘Sting.’ In: Jaishankar, K., ed. Cyber Criminology: Exploring Internet Crimes and Criminal Behavior. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press, 79-102;
43
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents