in order to unambiguously describe cybercrime conduct, criminal laws may require the introduction of new ‘information-related’ legal objects, as well as extended protection of traditional legal interests against new forms of computer-related acts. New objects required may include definitions such as ‘computer data’ or ‘computer information’, and legal interests such as the ‘integrity’ of computer systems. Through such concepts, the criminal law has the tools to protect against violation of the ‘cyber’-interests that persons have – for example, in controlling access to a computer system that they own. Different legal systems have different basic criteria for identifying conduct that may legitimately be the object of criminal law.8 The systematic application of these criteria to cyberrelated conduct can be challenging. Nonetheless, in many national systems, and in some international or regional initiatives, there is evidence of theoretical work that aims to underpin the criminalization of cyber-conduct. The Explanatory Report to the Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention, for example, refers extensively to ‘legal interests’ and the ‘harms’ at stake.9 Where a strong justification for the criminalization of a particular conduct does not exist, a risk of overcriminalization arises. In this respect, international human rights law represents one important tool for the assessment of criminal laws against an external, international standard. Chapter Four (Criminalization) of this Study examines further a number of common cybercrime offences and their construction both in national and international law. In addition to the specific conduct criminalized, any study of cybercrime offences must take into account the general part of criminal law. This is the part that deals with issues applicable to all offences, such as complicity, attempt, omission, state of mind (intent), defences, and criminal liability of legal persons. Cybercrime offences are, in general, subject to the general part of criminal law in the same way as for any other specific offence. Many responding countries indicated, for example, that ‘generally’ criminal offences are limited to intentional acts.10 Nonetheless, such general positions can be amended for particular acts – such as where a ‘specific intent’ is required. Chapter Four (Criminalization) examines this issue in greater depth. Procedural powers – An effective investigation of crime is not possible without adequate investigative powers. Due to their often intrusive nature, such measures must be regulated by law and accompanied by adequate safeguards. While some investigative actions can be achieved with traditional powers, many procedural provisions do not translate well from a spatial, object-oriented approach to one involving electronic data storage and real-time data flows. Specialized powers are therefore required, such as for the gathering of electronically stored and communicated computer content, for the identification and localisation of computer devices and communications, for the quick ‘freeze’ of volatile computer data, and for ‘undercover’ online investigations.11 Such powers are not only required for the investigation of ‘cybercrime’ itself¸ but also for the investigation of any crime generating electronic evidence. Chapter Five (Law enforcement and investigations) examines a number of specialized investigatory powers found in national and international laws. Gathering and using evidence – Traditional criminal procedural law typically contains provisions on the gathering and admissibility of evidence. When it comes to evidence in electronic form, 8 9 10 11 11 U.S. 32 (1812); Dubber, M., 1999. Reforming American Penal Law. Journal of American Criminal Law and Criminology, 90(1)49-114; and Simester, A.P., Spencer, J.R., Sullivan, G.R., Virgo, G.J., 2010. Criminal Law. 4th ed. Oxford/Portland: Hart Publishing, p.46. Including concepts such as harm, offense, wrongfulness, morality, paternalism, legal goods and deterrence. See Ashworth, A., 2006. Principles of Criminal Law. 6th ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press, p.27; Dubber, H., 2005. Positive Generalprävention und Rechtsgutstheorie. Zeitschrift für die gesamte Strafrechtswissenschaft, pp. 485-518, pp.504 et seq.; Hassemer, W., 1980. Theorie und Soziologie des Verbrechens. Frankfurt a.M.; Feinberg, J. 1984. Harm to Others. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Council of Europe. 2001. Explanatory Report to the Convention on Cybercrime. Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q40. Sieber, U., 2012. Straftaten und Strafverfolgung im Internet. In: Gutachten des Deutschen Juristentags. Munich: C.H. Beck, pp.C14-15. 54

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents