CHAPTER THREE: LEGISLATION AND FRAMEWORKS
computer data can be altered easily. Thus, the gathering and handling of electronic evidence must
guarantee the integrity, authenticity and continuity of evidence during the entire time period between
its seizure and its use in trial – a process often known as the ‘chain of custody.’ Country responses
to the study questionnaire highlight that while some countries create special evidential rules for
electronic evidence, others prefer to treat it in the same way as all other forms of evidence. In jurybased common law countries, laws may deal more extensively with evidence and admissibility rules,
whereas continental law countries often rely on the principle of free judicial evaluation of evidence.12
Chapter Six (Electronic evidence and criminal justice) examines the issue of electronic evidence in
greater depth.
Regulation and risk – Criminal law focuses on bringing offenders responsible for past acts to
justice. Regulatory and risk reduction or anticipation laws, on the other hand, aim at reducing the
risk that future acts will occur, or at making it easier for law enforcement authorities to carry out law
enforcement investigations and criminal justice actions should acts occur.13 With respect to
cybercrime, a number of approaches, including internet filtering, data protection, data retention, and
pro-active actions against criminal infrastructure fall within this category. The ‘anticipatory’ nature of
laws authorizing many of these actions requires that they be accompanied by particular safeguards,
in order to ensure that they do not represent disproportionate infringements of individual rights, or
unnecessarily involve the use of coercive powers.14 Chapter Eight (Prevention) examines, amongst
other prevention aspects, a number of such regulatory frameworks.
Jurisdiction and international cooperation – More than half of responding countries reported that
between 50 and 100 per cent of cybercrime acts encountered by police involved a ‘transnational
element.’15 The prosecution of transnational acts requires states to assert two types of ‘jurisdiction’ –
both substantive and investigative. Firstly, states must be able to assert that their national criminal
law applies to an act that takes place only partly, or even not at all, within its national territory.
Secondly, states need to be able to carry out investigative actions that concern the territory of other
states. In so far as investigations may involve infringements on the sovereignty of states, formal and
informal processes of consent and international cooperation are required. Many of these are at the
level of international treaty law, both multilateral and bilateral. National laws, however, can also
specify procedures to be applied, or create bases for cooperation in their own right. Chapter Seven
(International cooperation) examines this area in detail.
12
13
14
15
Damaska, M.R., 1973. Evidentiary Barriers to Conviction and Two Models of Criminal Procedure: A Comparative Study. University
of Pennsylvania Law Review 121(3):506-589 (1972-73).
Sieber, U., 2012. Straftaten und Strafverfolgung im Internet. In: Gutachten des Deutschen Juristentags. Munich: C.H. Beck, note 1, pp.C
69-74.
See European Commission. 2012. Safeguarding Privacy in a Connected World – A European Data Protection Framework for the 21st Century,
COM(2012) 9 final. Available at: http://ec.europa.eu/justice/data-protection/document/review2012/com_2012_9_en.pdf
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q83.
55
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents