3.2 Divergence and harmonization of laws
Key results:
Harmonization of cybercrime laws is essential for, inter alia, the elimination of criminal
safe havens, and global evidence collection
Divergences in national cybercrime laws derive from a range of factors, including
underlying legal and constitutional differences
The area of cybercrime offence penalties well exemplifies divergences in national
approaches to cybercrime acts. Examination of just one crime – illegal access – shows
considerable difference in its perceived degree of seriousness
One-third of responding countries report that their legislation is highly, or very highly
harmonized with countries viewed as important for the purposes of international
cooperation
This varies regionally, however, with higher degrees of harmonization reported by
countries in the Americas and Europe
This may be due to the use, in some regions, of multilateral instruments, which are
inherently designed to play a role in harmonization
Underlying differences in laws
In today’s globalized world, the
law consists of a multitude of national,
regional and international legal systems.
Interactions between these systems occur
at multiple levels. As a result, provisions
sometimes contradict each other, leading
to collisions of law, or fail to overlap
sufficiently, leaving jurisdictional gaps.16
Criminalization differences – Case example
A citizen of a country in Oceania uploaded legal material
containing forms of hate speech on a server in his own
country. The material was downloaded in a European country.
When the individual later travelled to that country in Europe,
he was arrested and sentenced to imprisonment for these acts,
which had not been criminal in his home country.
The case was appealed. The Federal High Court of the
Cybercrime is by no means the
European country upheld the conviction. It argued that
first ‘new’ form of crime to engage
although the accused neither acted in the European country
nor actively sent his data to this country, he nonetheless
multiple jurisdictions and laws. Illicit
threatened the public peace within the territory, as required by
trafficking flows in drugs, people and
the relevant statute The court stressed, however, that the
interpretation could not be generalized for other statutes on
weapons, for example, frequently originate
illegal content.
and end in different hemispheres, passing
through many countries in between.
Source: Judgement of the German Bundesgerichtshof of 1 December
2000 (1 StR 184/00, please see BGH MMR 2001, pp.228 et seqq.)
Nonetheless, cybercrime acts can engage
legal jurisdictions within the timeframe of
milliseconds. Computer content, for
example, can be legally stored on a computer server in one country, but downloaded through the
internet in multiple countries, some of which may consider the content to be illegal.17
16
17
Sieber, U., 2010. Legal Order in a Global World. In: Von Bogdandy, A., Wolfrum, R. (eds.) Max Planck Yearbook of United Nations
Law, 14:1-49.
Sieber, U., 2008. Mastering Complexity in the Global Cyberspace. In: Delmas-Marty, M., Pieth, M., and Sieber, U. (eds.) Les chemins
de l’harmonization pénale. Paris, pp.127-202 (192-197).
56
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents