confidentiality, integrity and availability of computer data and systems, computer-related acts for personal or financial gain, and specific computer-related acts.53 Figures 3.4 and 3.5 show the distribution of penalties for the acts of ‘mere illegal access’ to a computer system or computer data, and for the same crime – but where ‘bypassing security’ or ‘dishonest intent’ is required by the national legal provision.54 For both crimes, it is apparent that a number of countries provide for maximum penalties of less than one year. In light of the fact that one year is typically the most common threshold for extradition purposes (and the one Figure 3.4: Mere illegal access to computer system or data used by instruments such as the maximum term of imprisonment Council of Europe Cybercrime Fine only 4% Convention, and the League of Arab States Convention), Less than 6 months 4% international cooperation in 6 months 6% respect of these offences (alone) in some countries may prove 1 year 20% The typical challenging.55 2 years sentences are certainly well below 24% the four year ‘serious crime’ 3 years 17% threshold used in the Organized Crime Convention. More than 3 years 26% Source: UNODC legislation review. (n=54) Such results must be interpreted with caution, however, regarding the picture of penalties applied in practice. Penalty levels in practice cannot easily be assessed solely with reference to specific criminal law provisions. Rather, they may be affected by general rules on sentencing, on aggravating and mitigating circumstances, or by specific qualifications and Figure 3.5: Illegal access (bypassing security or dishonest intent) sentencing guidelines. maximum term of imprisonment Nonetheless, the picture serves to highlight the general challenges encountered when it comes to defining the scope of international cooperation and common agreement on cybercrime offence seriousness. On the one hand, the act of ‘mere illegal access’ could cover comparatively minor conduct. On the other hand, illegal access represents the starting point for many serious cybercrime acts, 53 54 55 6 months 17% 1 year 17% 2 years 17% 3 years More than 3 years 35% 13% Source: UNODC legislation review (n=23) Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q25-39. Information on penalties was also gathered by the Secretariat from additional sources included in the primary source legislation review. Analysis limited to countries in which the maximum penalty is indicated in the specific legal article (thus not including countries for which the punishment can only be determined by analysing general provisions of the criminal code). Although note that responding countries also reported that cybercrime acts are widely considered to meet seriousness standards and to constitute extraditable offences. All responding countries in Europe and the Americas, and 90 per cent of countries in Africa, Asia and Oceania reported that cybercrime acts are, in general, extraditable offences (Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q194). The discrepancy likely arises from the fact that it is rare for perpetrators to be charged with, and extradition sought, for ‘illegal access’ in isolation from other charges. 62

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents