CHAPTER THREE: LEGISLATION AND FRAMEWORKS
Convention. The Draft African Union Convention incorporates language from the ECOWAS Draft
Directive, and the Commonwealth of Independent States Agreement and Shanghai Cooperation
Organization Agreement show some common concepts related to computer information security.
Similarities and differences between the instruments and clusters can be illustrated with
reference to the schema below, focusing on ‘legal status’, ‘geographic scope’, ‘substantive focus’,
and ‘mechanisms.’
Legal status
A first important distinction
Legal status
Geographic scope
concerns whether an instrument is
legally binding. A number of the
Binding
Non-restricted
instruments – notably the Council of
Non-binding
Defined
Europe Conventions, the European
Union
instruments,
the
Substantive focus
Mechanisms
Commonwealth of Independent
Criminalization
Generic obligations
o List of crimes
Extradition
States Agreement, the Shanghai
o Specific crime
Mutual assistance
Cooperation
Organization
International cooperation
Focal points
and jurisdiction
Agreement, and the League of Arab
Procedural powers
States Convention – are express
Cybersecurity
E-commerce
agreements between states intended
to create legal obligations.58 If
approved by the Assembly of the
African Union, the Draft African Union Convention would also be open for signature, ratification
or accession, with entry into force in the form of a binding instrument.59
Other instruments – such as the Commonwealth Model Law, the COMESA Draft Model
Bill, the League of Arab States Model Law, and the ITU/CARICOM/CTU Model Legislative Texts
– are not intended to create legal obligations for states. Rather, they are designed to serve as
inspiration or ‘models’ for development of national legislative provisions. Non-binding instruments
may nonetheless have a significant influence at the global or regional level when many states choose
to align their national laws with model approaches.60 In addition, countries that have not ratified or
acceded to a binding instrument may nonetheless make use of a binding instrument as inspiration
for national legislative provisions – with the result that the reach of an instrument can be broader
than the number of countries that have signed, ratified or acceded.61
Geographic scope
For binding instruments, the geographic scope is typically determined by the nature and
58
59
60
61
‘International conventions’, whether general or particular, establishing rules expressly recognized, are included as a source of
international law to be applied by the International Court of Justice under Article 38 of the Statute of the International Court of
Justice. Article 2 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties defines a ‘treaty’ as an ‘international agreement concluded
between States in written form and governed by international law, whether embodied in a single instrument or in two or more
related instruments and whatever its particular designation.’
Draft African Union Convention. Part IV, Section 2. In September 2012, the 4th Ordinary Session of the African Union
Conference of Ministers in Charge of Communication and Information Technologies (CITMC-4) requested the Draft African
Union Convention to be submitted by the African Union Commission for adoption according to African Union rules of
procedure. See African Union. 2012. Khartoum Declaration. AU/CITMC-4/MIN/Decl.(IV)Rev 2, 6 September 2012.
A number of states in the Commonwealth, for example, have used provisions from the Commonwealth Model Law either alone, or
in conjunction with the Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention. See Council of Europe. 2012. Commonwealth States: Use of the
Budapest Convention and Commonwealth Model Law. Council of Europe’s contribution to the Commonwealth Working Group on Cybercrime.
The Council of Europe, for example, reports that, in addition to the countries that have ratified, signed or been invited to accede to
the Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention, it has engaged with at least 55 countries in technical cooperation on the basis of
the Convention. See Seger, A., 2012. The Budapest Convention on Cybercrime 10 years on: Lessons learnt or the web is a web.
65
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents