CHAPTER THREE: LEGISLATION AND FRAMEWORKS infrastructures.86 The Draft African Union Convention takes a cybersecurity-based approach that includes organization of electronic transactions, protection of personal data, promotion of cybersecurity, e-governance and combating cybercrime.87 Such differences significantly affect the way in which cybercrime is ‘framed’ within the international or regional legal response. Due to its broader focus on international information security, for example, the Shanghai Cooperation Organization Agreement does not set out specific cyber acts that should be criminalized. Similarly – perhaps due to its focus on cybersecurity as a whole, rather than criminal justice in particular – the Draft African Union Convention presently does not seek to establish mechanisms of international cooperation in cybercrime criminal matters. From the crime prevention and criminal justice perspective, six key areas may benefit from either binding or non-binding guidance at international or regional level: (i) criminalization; (ii) law enforcement procedural powers; (iii) procedures regarding electronic evidence; (iv) state jurisdiction in cybercrime criminal matters; (v) international cooperation in cybercrime criminal matters; and (vi) the responsibility of service providers. The substance of international and regional instruments – and, indeed, national laws – in each of these areas can be analysed on three levels: (1) the existence of relevant provisions in each area; (2) the coverage of the provisions within each area; and (3) the content of provisions. This section is concerned with levels one and two. Level three is examined in Chapter Four (Criminalization) and Chapter Five (Law enforcement and investigations). With respect to the existence of relevant provisions, the binding and non-binding international and regional instruments identified address the six areas to different extents. Provisions on criminalization, procedural powers, jurisdiction and Figure 3.8: Structure of international and regional instruments international cooperation are Criminalization 30 commonly found in a number of 25 binding instruments. In contrast, 20 15 provisions on electronic evidence 10 and service provider responsibility 5 are more commonly addressed in International cooperation Procedural powers 0 non-binding instruments – such as the Commonwealth Model Law, the COMESA Draft Model Bill, and the ITU/CARICOM/CTU Jurisdiction Model Legislative Texts.88 Only the Draft African Union Convention (envisaged to be binding) League of Arab States Convention Commonwealth of Independent States Agreement ECOWAS Draft Directive and the Shanghai Cooperation Organization Agreement Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention Draft African Union Convention contain provisions relevant to electronic evidence.89 Similarly, only European Union legislation addresses the issue of service 86 87 88 89 Article 2 of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization Agreement includes cybercrime as a ‘major threat’ to international information security. ‘Cybercrime’ is defined in Annex 1 to the Agreement as ‘the use of information resources and (or) the impact on them in the information space for illegal purposes.’ In the Draft African Union Convention, cybercrime is addressed in Part Three: ‘Promoting cybersecurity and combating cybercrime.’ Parts One and Two address ‘Electronic transactions’ and ‘Personal data protection’, respectively. See tables ‘Electronic evidence’ and ‘Service provider liability and responsibility’ at Annex Three to this Study. See ECOWAS Draft Directive, Art. 34, and Draft African Union Convention, Art. I(24). 69

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents