commonly, however, illegal remaining is not specifically criminalized at all. From the countries
included in the primary source legislation analysis, only nine countries, distributed across regions,
criminalized illegal remaining. Eight do so through incorporation into an illegal access provision,
while one does so in a separate provision.
Illegal interception of computer data
Criminalization of illegal interception extends protection of the integrity and confidentiality
of computer data from data residing in a system to
all transmitted data. A primary concern behind
Illegal interception: ECOWAS Draft Directive
prohibition of the interception of computer data in
Article 6 – Fraudulent interception of
transmission is the breach of confidentiality in
computer data
31
private communications.
The act by which a person fraudulently intercepts
or attempts to intercept computerized data during
Nine international instruments include
their non-public transmission to, from or within a
computer system through technical means.
specific provisions criminalizing interception of
32
computer data. At the national level, while many
countries have specific offences covering interception of computer data, others apply existing laws,
including prohibitions on the interception of communications in general. One reason for this is the
fact that interception of computer data can be viewed from either, or both, of the perspectives of
integrity of data, or the protection of privacy.
The Study cybercrime questionnaire asked about illegal interception of computer data in the
context of interception, access or acquisition of computer data. Thus the Study did not collect direct
information on illegal interception
Figure 4.6: Criminalization of illegal access, interception or
separately. Nonetheless, Figure 4.6
acquisition of computer data
shows that 85 per cent of responding
5%
Yes, cyber‐specific offence
10%
countries
have
provisions
Yes, general offence
criminalizing illegal interception,
Yes, both
access to, or acquisition of computer
No, not a criminal offence
data. In just over 65 per cent of
countries this is by way of a cyber19%
specific offence. For those countries
66%
that have a cyber-specific offence of
illegal interception, analysis of primary
source legislation shows differences
Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q26. (n=59)
between the object of the offence and
the acts covered.
Offence object – Most multilateral cybercrime instruments define the object of illegal
interception as ‘non-public’ transmission of computer data, thus limiting the object to ‘private’
transmissions. This limitation refers to the intended nature of the transmission. For example, a
communication that has a private nature but is sent via public Wi-Fi network can be protected for
the purposes of illegal interception, even though the transmission goes through a public network.33
The only document that does not limit criminalization to non-public transmission is the League of
31
32
33
Walden, I., 2007. Computer Crime and Digital Investigations. Oxford: OUP, p.184.
Draft African Union Convention (Art. III-23); COMESA Draft Model Bill, Art. 21; Commonwealth Model Law, Art. 8; Council of
Europe Cybercrime Convention, Art. 3; ECOWAS Draft Directive, Art. 6; EU Directive Proposal on Attacks against Information
Systems, Art. 6; ITU/CARICOM/CTU Model Legislative Texts, Art. 6; League of Arab States Convention, Art. 7; League of Arab
States Model Law, Art. 8.
See, for example, Council of Europe, 2001. Explanatory Report to Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention, ETS No. 185.
86
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents