CHAPTER FIVE: LAW ENFORCEMENT AND INVESTIGATIONS
What do the police encounter?
During information gathering for the Study, responding countries stated that more than 90
per cent of acts that come to the attention of the police do so through reports from individual and
company victims.10 The remainder of acts were reported to be detected directly by police
investigators or obtained from ISP reports.
The picture of cybercrime seen by law enforcement is, as with any crime, necessarily
incomplete – being constructed from a mixture of individual investigated cases and broader criminal
intelligence. The transnational nature of cybercrime exacerbates the challenge, as investigative leads
arrive at overseas servers or IP-addresses, creating delays while formal or informal cooperation
mechanisms are engaged.
As noted by one
Figure 5.1: Sources of cybercrime reports to police
responding country in
Africa, for example,
13%
‘Most of the crimes, including
Individual victims
the unreported ones, involve
Company victims
transnational dimensions.
7%
Police investigators
Targets are mostly outside of
11
national
boundaries.’
ISPs
2%
Another country, also in
Africa, reported that
‘Most of the reported offences
78%
are initiated outside this
country. In most cases we act
Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q78. (n=61)
as a conduit,’ while one
country in Europe highlighted that ‘All cybercrime investigations conducted in the last five years have had a
transnational dimension. Examples are offences related to use of e-mail accounts, social media and proxy servers.’12
In addition to transnational elements, significant underreporting of cybercrime acts in the
first place can contribute to a limited picture of the underlying phenomenon. Of the 90 per cent of
cybercrime acts that come to the attention of the police through victim reporting, countries estimate
that the proportion of actual cybercrime victimization reported to the police ranges upwards from
only one per cent.13 One survey conducted by a private sector organization suggests that 80 per cent
of individual victims of core cybercrime acts do not report the crime to the police.14
Responding countries to the Study cybercrime questionnaire attributed underreporting of
cybercrime acts to a number of factors, including a lack of public confidence in the capacity of
police to address cybercrime, a lack of awareness of victimization and of reporting mechanisms,
victim shame and embarrassment, and perceived reputation risks for corporations. One country, for
example, stated that: ‘Estimation is very difficult. Companies and banks are not interested in reporting cybercrimes
due to reputational risks.’15 Another highlighted that ‘Most victims do not even realize that [they] have become
targets or the damage done is insignificant enough for them to ignore.’16 When cases do come to the attention of
the police, subsequent investigation may reveal a much wider pool of victims and offenders than
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q78.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q83.
Ibid.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q82.
Symantec. 2012. Norton Cybercrime Report 2012.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q82.
Ibid.
119
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents