CHAPTER SEVEN: INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION
Where rules do exist, they
Figure 7.12: Policy for use of informal cooperation rather
were reported to be contained
than MLA
within national legislation, such as
Europe
mutual assistance in criminal
Yes
(n=10)
180
matters acts. Practice varies, in
No
Asia & Oceania
particular, regarding who is
(n=16)
designated to authorize informal
Americas
(n=7)
assistance. Options given ranged
Africa
from the local superintendent or
(n=6)
senior investigating officer, to the
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
head of the cybercrime division,
to the case prosecutor or any
Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q 224. (n=39)
judicial authority, to the Ministry
of Justice.181 The majority of countries tended to allow for decisions at the investigative level – by
the local police or prosecutor, at times in concert with respective heads of agency.182 One country
from South-East Asia, for instance, noted that while the Office of the Attorney General is involved
in formal requests, its involvement is not mandatory for assistance provided through informal
cooperation channels.183
Forms of informal cooperation
A general lack of policies did not, however, prevent countries from clearly indicating the
types of assistance that can be provided through informal cooperation – albeit with some variation.
Countries reported that general technical and legal advice is exchanged with counterparts in foreign
law enforcement agencies almost on a daily basis. The majority of this information concerns joint
investigations
or Figure 7.13: Forms of informal cooperation with law enforcement agencies
general
operational
intelligence.184 Almost
General technical advice
42%
all
responding
General legal advice
39%
countries were able to
Identity or subscriber information for a suspect
35%
provide
such
Conduct of a joint investigation
35%
information
Expedited preservation of computer data
23%
informally, with only
10 per cent of
Other (unspecified)
10%
countries stating that
Provisional arrest of a suspect
3%
‘all informal requests are
Search for computer hardware or data
3%
referred to the mutual legal
Seizure of computer hardware or data
3%
assistance authority.’185
Stored traffic data from a service provider
3%
Some countries went
Source: Study cybercrime questionnnaire. Q106. (n=31, r=61)
further, and indicated
that sharing of some personal data (including holders of telephone and post box numbers,
information from hotel registers, and holders of IP addresses available without compulsory
measures), obtaining public records such as criminal records, the taking of voluntary witness
statements, and surveillance could be provided through direct law enforcement cooperation.186
Generally, however, requests for specific investigative measures, such as expedited
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
Ibid.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q106, Q223 and Q224.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q106.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q223.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q106.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q223.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q106.
211
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents