of a Facebook account.216 In effect, the interests of the state where the cloud data is stored lose
relevance in relation to the interest of the state on whose territory the data is ‘controlled.’217
Such challenges were highlighted by countries during information gathering for the Study.
When asked, for example, about obtaining electronic evidence from service providers located in
another jurisdiction, a number of countries commented that the process of obtaining extra-territorial
data is lengthy, with difficulties in locating ‘foreign authorities with both the legal authority and technical
expertise in the places where digital evidence is physically located.’218
International and regional approaches
The challenges of obtaining extra-territorial data controlled by third parties have been
recognized for a long time. During the drafting of the Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention,
for example, Article 32 was included with the aim of allowing Parties, without the authorization of
another Party, to: (a) access publicly available (open source) stored computer data, regardless of
where the data is located geographically; and (b) to access or receive, through a computer system in
its territory, stored computer data located in another Party, if the Party obtains the lawful and
voluntary consent of the person who has the lawful authority to disclose the data to the Party
through that computer system.219 An article has since been included in almost identical terms in the
League of Arab States Convention.220
As it is particularly relevant to the obtaining of extra-territorial data in law enforcement
investigations, this discussion focuses on the actions described by Article 32(b) of the Council of
Europe Cybercrime Convention (access to stored data with consent). Such actions are commonly
termed ‘trans-border’ access.
Article 32(b) is drafted in permissive terms, insofar as it envisages that States parties to the
Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention may undertake such actions. It does not directly prohibit
States parties from preventing other States parties so accessing data stored in their territory – but
were a State party to do so, this could be considered incompatible with the spirit of the Article.
Access ‘without authorization’ of another State party is interpreted as ‘to unilaterally access computer data
stored in another Party without seeking mutual assistance.’221 The Article is silent on the point of notification
to the other Party – neither prohibiting it nor requiring it. It should also be noted that Article 32(b)
concerns the access or receipt of stored ‘computer data’ in general, and is not limited to the context
of cybercrime investigations. One perspective is that Article 32(b) constitutes a rule validly
permitting the exercise of state power on the territory of another within the exceptions foreseen by
international law.222 Another is that such access is incompatible with the principle of sovereignty and
non-interference, if carried out without the consent of the state on whose territory the data is
stored.223 A third perspective is that such actions do not meet the threshold of ‘interference’ in the
internal or external affairs of the state on whose territory the data is stored.224
216
217
218
219
220
221
222
223
224
Ibid.
Sieber, U., 2012. Straftaten und Strafverfolgung im Internet. Gutachten C zum 69. Deutschen Juristentag. Munich: C.H. Beck.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q105.
See, Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention, Art. 32.
See, League of Arab States Convention, Art. 40.
Council of Europe, Cybercrime Convention Committee (T-CY), Ad-hoc Sub-group on Jurisdiction and Transborder Access to
Data, 2012. Transborder access and jurisdiction: What are the options? T-CY (2012)3. 6 December, p.21.
Ibid. At p.27, citing ‘a permissive rule derived from international custom or convention’ as contained in the Lotus case, PCIJ Series A., No.10, at
18 (1927).
Sieber, U., 2012. Straftaten und Strafverfolgung im Internet. Gutachten C zum 69. Deutschen Juristentag. Munich: C.H. Beck.
Council of Europe, Cybercrime Convention Committee (T-CY), Ad-hoc Sub-group on Jurisdiction and Transborder Access to
Data, 2012. Transborder access and jurisdiction: What are the options? T-CY (2012)3. 6 December, p.27.
218
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents