CHAPTER SEVEN: INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION
a number of means, direct access to extra-territorial data does occur, in practice, in the course of
investigations – either with or without the knowledge of investigators. Driving forces for this
include the length of time required for formal cooperation procedures; situations where devices with
live connections are encountered; and where access credentials become known in the course of an
investigation.
Current international and regional approaches present a number of limitations through a
focus on ‘consent’ and presumed knowledge of the ‘location’ of data. In reality, ‘true’ data location is
rarely known at the outset of an investigation, or at the point at which data access may be required.
Even where formal mutual legal assistance requests are used, these may be directed to the
jurisdiction of the seat of the cloud service provider, rather than the jurisdiction of the physical data
centre.244
From a crime prevention and criminal justice perspective, a number of circumstances exist
in which urgent access to cloud data can be required – including where there is an imminent threat
of harm. Achieving consensus on the most effective way in which this might be achieved while
ensuring respect for individual human rights245 will require: (i) (re)-conceptualization of the extent to
which ‘data location’ can still be used as a guiding principle; and (ii) the development of common
standards and safeguards concerning the circumstances, if any, under which direct access to extraterritorial data may be conducted by law enforcement.
244
245
Conceivably, agreements between operators of data centres owned by global companies and host countries could address this
point.
See Chapter Five (Law enforcement and investigations), Section 5.3 Privacy and investigative measures.
223
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents