While physical objects can usually be attributed exclusively to certain owners, attribution of
information ownership can be significantly more challenging. This difference is relevant, for example,
to the legal concept of ‘theft’, applied in the traditional laws of many countries. A ‘theft’ of
computer data, for instance – even given the extension of the concept of objects to include data or
information – may not fall within the scope of the constituent elements of traditional theft. The data
would still remain in the possession of the original bearer, thus (depending upon national law
approaches) possibly not meeting required legal elements, such as ‘expropriation’ or ‘taking’ of the
object. Similarly, legal references to a public or private ‘place’ in harassment or stalking laws may, or
may not (again, depending upon national
approaches) extend to online ‘places.’ Such
examples illustrate a potential need – in some areas
Functions of cybercrime legislation
– for the adaptation of legal doctrines to new
information technologies.1
Setting clear standards of behaviour for the
use of computer devices
Deterring perpetrators and protecting
citizens
Enabling law enforcement investigations
while protecting individual privacy
Providing fair and effective criminal justice
procedures
Requiring minimum protection standards in
areas such as data handling and retention
Enabling cooperation between countries in
criminal matters involving cybercrime and
electronic evidence
This raises the question of whether
cybercrime should be covered by general, existing
criminal law provisions, or whether new, computerspecific offences are required. The question cannot
be answered generally, but rather depends upon the
nature of individual acts, and the scope and
interpretation of national laws. Chapter Four
(Criminalization) of this Study examines the use of
specialized, and general, laws in the criminalization
of cybercrime acts. Country responses show that
some ‘core’ cybercrime offences are covered by cyber-specific offences, while others are covered by
general offences.2 Chapters Five (Law enforcement and investigations) and Eight (Prevention)
consider the use of information-specific or cyber-specific laws that may be required in areas such as
law enforcement investigative powers3 and the liability of internet service providers.4
Relevant categories of law
While criminal law is often perceived as being most relevant when it comes to cybercrime,
possible legal responses also include the use of civil law (which addresses the legal relationship
between persons), and administrative law (which addresses the legal relationship between persons and
the state). Further divisions within these legal regimes include substantive and procedural law, as well as
regulatory and constitutional, or rights-based, laws. In many legal systems, each of these regimes are
characterized by specific aims, institutions, and safeguards. Cybercrime laws are most usually found
within the areas of substantive and procedural criminal law. However, a number of other areas of
law are also important.
In particular, the range of computer-related acts that the state may wish to regulate will not
always require the use of intrusive criminal law measures. Computer-related acts that are considered
minor infringements, for example, may be addressed by civil and administrative regulations, rather
1
2
3
4
Sieber, U., 2012. Straftaten und Strafverfolgung im Internet. In: Gutachten des Deutschen Juristentags, Munich: C.H. Beck, pp.C 14-15.
See Chapter Four (Criminalization), Section 4.1 Criminalization overview, Cyber-specific and general offences.
Existing studies propose that computer-specific provisions are required in investigative powers in order to permit actions such as
expedited preservation of data and the use of remote forensics tools; see Sieber, U., 2012. Straftaten und Strafverfolgung im
Internet, In: Gutachten des Deutschen Juristentags. Munich: C.H. Beck, pp.C 62-72, 103-128.
The transmission or hosting of large volumes of third-party content by internet service providers, for example, renders
impracticable the application of traditional liability rules applicable to the press and media – who are often obliged to control
content prior to publication. Rather, general liability is replaced by specific conditions, including ‘notice’ and ‘take-down’
procedures. See Chapter Eight (Prevention), Section 8.3 Cybercrime prevention, the private sector, and academia, Cybercrime
prevention by internet service and hosting providers.
52
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents