CHAPTER THREE: LEGISLATION AND FRAMEWORKS
could still be maintained by ‘taking into account the specificity of society in terms of customs, traditions and
usages… [and] pre-existing national legislation.’33
The degree of harmonization of cybercrime laws reported by responding countries varies
significantly depending upon region, and upon whether harmonization was considered with respect
to: (i) other countries; (ii) within the region; or (iii) the provisions of multilateral instruments.
Overall, Figure 3.3 below shows that around one-third of countries reported that their legislation
was either ‘very highly’ or ‘highly’ harmonized with other countries. The remainder view their
legislation as ‘partially’ or ‘somewhat’ harmonized with other countries. Levels of perceived
harmonization tend to be higher in Europe and the Americas, than in Africa, Asia and Oceania. One
country in Asia, for example, commented directly that ‘current legislation is not harmonized with countries
that are important… for the purposes of international cooperation.’34 Other countries referred to the global
situation. One country in Europe, for example, noted that ‘at regional level there is a high degree of
harmonization. At global level we are not aware if it is the same. Although no international judicial cooperation
request was [yet] refused to us based on the lack of double criminality requirements, it is apparent that different
procedural rules… [exist] related to international judicial cooperation.’35
Africa
(n=6)
Americas
(n=8)
Asia &
Oceania
(n=12)
Europe
(n=12)
Many countries commented on the utility of international instruments in processes of
harmonization. One country, for example, reported finding it useful to have external standards, such
as those found in international and regional instruments, ‘against which we could compare the provisions of
our laws.’36 Another noted that international fora seeking consensus on international strategies and
legal measures against cybercrime were important as they represented ‘opportunities to share ideas which
can be taken up by any Member State as useful legislative or practical options for preventing and suppressing crime.’
The same country observed that harmonization processes represented a two-way process, as ‘in some
cases… domestic legislative initiatives or ideas have been the source of elements in international norms, and it other
cases,
ideas
Figure 3.3: Degree of harmonization of cybercrime legislation with: (i) other countries
expressed
by
important for cooperation, (ii) the Region, and (iii) multilateral instruments
other Member
States
have
Other countries
influenced
Within region
Very Highly
[national]
International/regional instruments
Highly
thinking about
Other countries
Partially
cybercrime, and
Within region
Somewhat
International/regional instruments
have found their
Other countries
way
into
Within region
[national] law as
International/regional instruments
a
result.’37
Other countries
Other
Within region
countries
International/regional instruments
noted
the
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
influence
of
Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q17. (n=38)
existing
national legislation. One country in Eastern Asia, for example, stated that it had ‘studied foreign
legislation…to establish national legislation.’38 Overall, Figure 3.3 is rather inconclusive as to the impact of
international instruments on harmonization. High levels of perceived harmonization of national
33
34
35
36
37
38
Ibid.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q17.
Ibid.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q16.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q17.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q16.
59
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents