CHAPTER FOUR: CRIMINALIZATION
cent of these countries report a cyber-specific offence. In 7 per cent of reporting countries, the act is
covered by both a cyber-specific and a general offence. Examination of primary source legislation
for 83 countries shows differences within national legislation concerning the object of the offence, the
state of mind required, and attached aggravating
Figure 4.10: Objects of data interference
circumstances.
1%
Data‐specific
Offence object – Most multilateral
instruments require the adoption of separate
provisions for criminalization of illegal
interference with computer data and computer
systems.39 Only the League of Arab States
Model Law combines the two concepts.40
Data‐and‐
system
31%
Unclear
68%
For the majority of national
legislation examined, data interference and
Source: UNODC legislation review. (n=83)
system interference were contained in separate
provisions. However, in around 30 per cent of
countries examined, the offences are not clearly separated, or data interference is only criminalized
when it has an effect on the functioning of a computer system. While this will often be the case in
practice, the approach could leave criminalization gaps for interference of computer data alone.
Nonetheless, in some countries this may still be covered by general criminal laws. One country in
the Americas, for example, makes use of
Figure 4.11: Objects of system interference
a general provision on destroying or
rendering defective ‘goods’ – in which the
15%
System
definition of ‘goods’ includes computer
Network
data.
Computer only
For the system element of illegal
interference, analysis of available
provisions shows that national laws most
often cover computer ‘systems’. In 30 per
70%
cent of countries, however, the offence
was limited either to computer ‘networks’
or ‘a computer’. This may limit
Source: UNODC legislation review. (n=81)
criminalization by excluding either cases
in which a computer that suffers damage is not ‘networked,’ or cases in which multiple devices,
including network routers, suffer interference, such as through a malware or DDoS attack.
15%
Acts covered – Multilateral instruments cover criminalization of different acts constituting
data interference, including not only damage to data but also ‘deletion’, ‘deterioration’, ‘alteration’,
‘suppression’, and even ‘inputting’ of data, thus protecting data integrity in a broad sense. Figure 4.12
shows that the majority of national laws examined cover damage, or deletion of data, and data
alteration. Only 35 per cent of countries included ‘inputting’ of data in interference provisions.
‘Suppressing’ data is covered in just over 40 per cent of countries. Only 12 per cent of countries
criminalize ‘transmission’ of data under data interference provisions. It might be expected that
‘transmission’ of data would be criminalized in countries where data and system interference are
39
40
Draft African Union Convention, Arts. III-19, III-20; COMESA Draft Model Bill, Art. 20-b; Commonwealth Model Law, Art. 6;
Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention, Art. 4; ECOWAS Draft Directive, Arts. 5, 7; EU Decision on Attacks against
Information Systems, Art. 3; EU Directive Proposal on Attacks against Information Systems, Art. 4; ITU/CARICOM/CTU
Model Legislative Texts, Art. 7; League of Arab States Convention, Art. 8.
League of Arab States Model Law, Art. 6.
89
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents