CHAPTER FOUR: CRIMINALIZATION
‘damaging’, ‘interfering’, and ‘hindering’, are included. Two broad legislative trends observed are either
the use of the term ‘hindering by any means,’ creating a broad basis for criminalization of system
interference, as well as the attachment of system interference provisions to ‘illegal access’ provisions,
creating a narrower basis.
State of mind – Many multilateral
cybercrime instruments require that the
crime of illegal data interference or
Damaging
77%
system interference be committed
‘intentionally’ or ‘fraudulently.’44 The
League of Arab States Model Law does
Interfering
63%
not mention intent in its data
interference provision. It does, however,
require the special purpose of stopping a
Hindering
75%
computer system or data functioning.45
A different approach is taken by the
Source: UNODC legislation review. (n=81)
Commonwealth Model Law, which
explicitly requires criminalization of interference acts committed recklessly.46 This creates a
particularly broad basis of criminalization in light of the fact that it is often easier to interfere
unintentionally with computer data or the operation of computer systems, than for objects or
property in the physical world.47 Out of 81
countries in which data interference
Illegal data interference: National example from a
provisions were reviewed, only six followed
country in South-Eastern Asia
this approach and criminalized reckless or
Unauthorized modification of the contents of any
negligent data interference. The majority of
computer
these were not members of the
(1) A person shall be guilty of an offence if he does any act
which he knows will cause unauthorized modification of
Commonwealth, but were found in South
the contents of any computer.
America, Western Europe, and Africa.
(2) For the purposes of this section, it is immaterial that the
Figure 4.14: Acts constituting illegal system interference
Aggravating circumstances – Multilateral
cybercrime instruments mostly do not
require aggravated penalties for illegal data
interference. There are two exceptions. The
COMESA Draft Model Bill provides for
aggravated penalties, where there is intent to
cause serious harm or to threaten public
safety, or intent to disrupt critical
infrastructure, or for terrorist purposes.48
The EU Directive Proposal on Attacks
against Information Systems(as in the case of
illegal access), requires countries to provide
aggravating
circumstances
for
the
44
45
46
47
48
act in question is not directed at—
(a) any particular program or data;
(b) a program or data of any kind; or
(c) a program or data held in any particular computer.
(3) For the purposes of this section, it is immaterial whether
an unauthorized modification is, or is intended to be,
permanent or merely temporary.
For the purposes of this Act, a modification of the contents
of any computer takes place if, by the operation of any
function of the computer concerned or any other
computer—
(a) any program or data held in the computer concerned is
altered or erased;
(b) any program or data is introduced or added to its
contents; or
(c) any event occurs which impairs the normal operation of
any computer,
and any act that contributes towards causing such a
modification shall be regarded as causing it.
Draft African Union Convention, Arts. III-19, III-20; COMESA Draft Model Bill, Art. 20-b; Council of Europe Cybercrime
Convention, Art. 4; ECOWAS Draft Directive, Arts. 5, 7; EU Decision on Attacks against Information Systems, Art. 3; EU
Directive Proposal on Attacks against Information Systems, Art. 4; ITU/CARICOM/CTU Model Legislative Texts, Art. 7; League
of Arab States Convention, Art. 8.
League of Arab States Model Law, Art. 6.
Commonwealth Model Law, Art. 6.
De Hert, P., Fuster, G. and Koops, B. J., 2006. Fighting cybercrime in the two Europes. The added value of the EU framework
decision and the Council of Europe Convention. International Review of Penal Law, 77:6.
COMESA Draft Model Bill, Art. 20-c, d, e, f.
91
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents