involvement of criminal organizations, through the use of tools designed to attack a significant
number of information systems, or when the real identity of the perpetrator is concealed.49
At the national level, many
Figure 4.15: Aggravated circumstances of illegal system
countries
that
criminalize
data
interference
interference have included aggravating
circumstances that attract more severe
Substantial harm
33%
sanctions. Figure 4.15 shows that these
most often include where the
Critical Infrastructure
36%
interference causes ‘substantial harm,’ or
where it involves interference with
‘critical infrastructure.’ A small number of
Terrorism
4%
countries in which legislation was
reviewed also included aggravating
Source: UNODC legislation review. (n=81)
circumstances where the interference is
linked with terrorism. Smaller numbers of laws also included aggravating circumstances for offences
committed in an organized manner, and acts committed with the intent to acquire property. A few
countries have also created additional protections for particular types of data. One country in Asia,
for example, has established an aggravated penalty for interference with medical and healthcare
records data.
Computer misuse tools
Software and other tools used to
commit crimes in the digital environment, as
well as victim passwords and access codes,
have become an illicit commodity in
underground
cybercrime
markets.50
Criminalization of such ‘crime objects’
encounters a number of challenges, not least
the fluid boundary between ‘preparation’ for
and ‘attempt’ at a criminal offence, as well as
the problem of ‘dual-use’ objects, which may
be used for either innocent or criminal
purposes. Nonetheless, precedents exist in the
control of ‘conventional’ crime for the
criminalization of objects such as ‘burglary
and
multilateral
cybercrime
tools’51
instruments have developed analogous
offences. The Explanatory Report to the
Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention,
for example, notes that one rationale for the
49
50
51
Computer misuse tools: Commonwealth Model
Law
Article 9(1) – Illegal devices
A person commits an offence if the person:
(a) intentionally or recklessly, without lawful excuse or
justification, produces, sells, procures for use, imports,
exports, distributes or otherwise makes available:
(i) a device, including a computer program, that is
designed or adapted for the purpose of committing an
offence against section 5, 6, 7 or 8; or
(ii) a computer password, access code or similar data
by which the whole or any part of a computer system
is capable of being accessed;
with the intent that it be used by any person for the
purpose of committing an offence against section 5, 6,
7 or 8; or
(b) has an item mentioned in subparagraph (i) or (ii) in
his or her possession with the intent that it be used by
any person for the purpose of committing an offence
against section 5, 6, 7 or 8.
(2) A person found guilty of an offence against this
section is liable to a penalty of imprisonment for a
period not exceeding ___, or a fine not exceeding
____, or both.
EU Directive Proposal on Attacks, Art. 10.
Europol, 2011. Threat assessment (abridged). Internet facilitated organised crime. iOCTA. File No.: 2530–264. The Hague. 7 January.
Available at: https://www.europol.europa.eu/sites/default/files/publications/iocta.pdf ; Fallmann, H., Wondracek, G. and Platzer,
C., 2010. Covertly probing underground economy marketplaces. Vienna University of Technology Secure Systems Lab. Available at:
http://www.iseclab.org/papers/dimva2010_underground.pdf
See, Fletcher, G., 1978. Rethinking Criminal Law. Boston: Little, Brown & Co. pp.199-202.
92
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents