CHAPTER FOUR: CRIMINALIZATION
criminalization of computer misuse tools is in order to target acts preceding offences such as
‘hacking’ and to prevent the creation of black markets in such items.52 In order to prevent
overcriminalization of unknowing possession, or possession with legitimate intent, of computer
misuse tools, international and regional instruments usually require a specific intent of use for the
purposes of an offence.
Figure 4.16 shows that
more than half of the countries that
responded
to
the
Study
questionnaire criminalize computer
misuse tools, mostly through use of
a cyber-specific offence. About 20
per cent of responding countries,
however, do not criminalize
computer misuse tools. Analysis of
primary source legislation for 70
countries that do contain such
provisions
reveals
diverse
approaches to the object of the crime,
the acts covered and the state of mind
required for the offence.
Figure 4.16: Criminalization of the production, distribution or
possession of computer misuse tools
Yes, cyber‐specific offence
21%
Yes, general offence
Yes, both
2%
No, not a criminal offence
10%
67%
Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q28. (n=57)
Offence object – Multilateral cybercrime instruments include provisions concerning two types
of computer misuse tools: (i) software and devices; and (ii) passwords and codes that enable access
to computer systems and data. Nine multilateral cybercrime instruments require criminalization of
both software and codes. One instrument, however (the Commonwealth of Independent States
Agreement) requires criminalization of the use and distribution of malicious software, therefore
excluding hardware and codes from the object of criminalization.53 Where used, the term ‘devices’
covers both hardware and software.
In addition to provisions covering tools to commit cybercrime in general, some multilateral
instruments also cover devices and
articles used to commit specific
Figure 4.17: Types of computer misuse tools
crimes. The EU Decision on Fraud
and Counterfeiting of non-cash means
Software
30%
of payment, for example, includes
61%
Codes
criminalization of ‘instruments, articles,
Both
computer programmes and any other means
peculiarly adapted for the commission of any
of the offences described under Art. 2 (b)’
(counterfeiting or falsification of a
payment instrument in order for it to
9%
be used fraudulently), as well as
‘computer programmes, the purpose of which
is the commission of any of the offences
Source: UNODC legislation review. (n=70)
described under Art. 3’ (computer-related
52
53
Council of Europe, 2001. Explanatory Report to Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention, ETS No. 185.
Commonwealth of Independent States Agreement, Art. 3(1)(b).
93
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents