offences, esp. computer-related fraud).54
National approaches to the object of illegal device offences show some diversity. Figure
4.17 shows that the majority of countries reviewed criminalize both devices and codes. A significant
number of national statutes limit criminalization, however, to either devices alone (30 per cent), or
passwords and codes alone (around 10 per cent). A different approach to the object is taken in other
countries, which criminalize the creation and dissemination of computer viruses instead of, or in
addition to, software and codes.
Figure 4.18: Intent requirement for computer misuse tool
Several countries also criminalize acts
offences
related to the possession and
distribution of ‘articles for computer
Perpetrator
14%
intended to use
fraud.’ Provisions criminalizing this
tool for offence
54%
kind of device were evident in 12 of
Tool primarily
designed for
70 countries examined.
offence
Both
Another
important
characteristic of the offence is the
32%
purpose of the tool. Most multilateral
instruments, for example, required
that a ‘misuse device’ has been
Source: UNODC legislation review. (n=70)
primarily designed for the commission
of an offence. In addition, many
instruments also require that the perpetrator intends to use the tool to commit a crime. Two
multilateral instruments (the Draft African Union Convention and the Commonwealth of
Independent States Agreement), however, address only the purpose of the tool and not the intent of
the perpetrator. Figure 4.18 shows that, at the national level, over 50 per cent of countries reviewed
also require both that the tool was primarily designed for the commission of an offence, and that the
perpetrator intended to use it for such.55 Some national approaches, however, focus only on the
purpose of the tool alone, or the intent of the perpetrator alone.
Computer misuse tools: National example from a country in Oceania
Telecommunications and Computer Offences(1) No person shall: …
(f) intentionally, without right and with dishonest or otherwise unlawful intent, use, possess, produce, sell, procure
for use, import, distribute or otherwise make available or attempt to use, possess, produce, sell, procure for use,
import, distribute otherwise make available a device, including but not limited to a computer program, for the
purpose of committing any of the offences established in paragraphs (a), (b), (c), (d) or (e);
(g) intentionally, without right and with dishonest or otherwise unlawful intent, use, possess, produce, sell, procure
for use, import, distribute or otherwise make available or attempt to use, possess, produce, sell, procure for use,
import, distribute or otherwise make available a computer password, access code or similar data by which the
whole or any part of a telecommunications network or computer system is capable of being accessed with intent
that such network or system be used for the purpose of committing nay of the offences established in
paragraphs (a), (b), (c), (d) or (e); …
(2) Every person who acts in contravention of any of the provisions in subsection (1) commits an offence and is liable
to the penalties provided in section ___.
Acts covered – Multilateral instruments include a wide range of acts related to computer
misuse tools, including: ‘producing’, ‘selling’, ‘importing’, ‘possessing’, ‘distributing’, ‘disseminating’, ‘offering’,
‘transferring’, and ‘making available’ such tools. As illustrated in Figure 4.19, analysis of national laws
54
55
EU Framework Decision 2001/413/JAI of 28 May 2001 (EU Decision on Fraud and Counterfeiting).
UNODC legislation review.
94
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents