Directive on Data Protection provides that ‘it is necessary to prohibit the use of false identities or false return
addresses or numbers while sending unsolicited messages for direct marketing purposes.’60 In addition, Article 13(3)
of the same Directive requires States to ‘take appropriate measures’ to ensure that, ‘free of charge, unsolicited
communications for purposes of direct marketing’ are not allowed without consent. The Directive does not,
however, explicitly require the establishment of a particular offence under the domestic laws of
Member states.
Responses to the Study cybercrime questionnaire indicate that sending or controlling
sending of spam is a criminal offence only in around one third of responding countries. Both cyberspecific and general offences are used.
Spam: National example from a country in Southern Asia
Review of available primary source
national legislation resulted in the
Penalty for damage to computer, computer system, etc.
identification of only nine countries out
If any person…
of almost 100 in which specific criminal
(h) for the purpose of advertisement of goods and services,
provisions on spam could be identified.
generates or causes generation of spams or sends unwanted
The object of spam offences varies from
electronic mails without any permission of the originator or
‘unsolicited bulk messages’ to criminalization
subscriber;…
(2) Every person who acts in contravention of any of the
of falsification of ‘message headers’ or
provisions in subsection (1) commits an offence and is liable to
‘origin’. One country in the Americas, for
the penalties provided in section ___.
example, has adopted criminal provisions
punishing the falsification of e-mail
subject lines. In some countries, it was also possible to identify administrative sanctions for sending
or controlling sending of spam.
The main acts that are the subject of spam criminalization include the ‘transmission’ of
unsolicited, multiple e-mails or acts that mislead the recipient of the message – such as by
‘manipulation’ of the header or originating information. As regards the mental element, the COMESA
Draft Model Bill requires that the act be intentional and committed for illegal purposes. The
ITU/CARICOM/CTU Model Legislative Texts also require the criminalization of intentional acts.
Intentionality is also required by those national provisions that could be identified and analysed.
While the problem of spam is not explicitly tackled by any binding international instrument,
a number of elements of the threat posed by spam, such as malware and phishing, are covered
through international and regional provisions protecting the integrity, availability and confidentiality
of computer data and systems.
Computer-related fraud and forgery
The protected legal interest in crimes against the confidentiality, integrity and availability of
computer data and systems is the integrity of computer information and data itself. In contrast,
criminal provisions on computer-related fraud and forgery protect interests in property, financial
assets and the authenticity of documents.61 At the international and regional level, eight instruments
contain provisions on criminalization of computer-related fraud.62 Acts covered in the instruments
60
61
62
EU Directive on Data Protection, Preamble (43).
Sieber, U., 1998. Legal Aspects of Computer-Related Crime in the Information Society COMCRIME-Study. Available at:
www.edc.uoc.gr/~panas/PATRA/sieber.pdf.
Draft African Union Convention, Art. III-26, III-41; COMESA Draft Model Bill, Art. 24; Council of Europe Cybercrime
Convention, Art. 8; ECOWAS Draft Directive, Art. 10; EU Decision on Fraud and Counterfeiting, Art. 2; ITU/CARICOM/CTU
Model Legislative Texts, Art. 12; League of Arab States Convention, Arts. 10, 11; League of Arab States Model Law, Arts. 10-12).
96
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents