CHAPTER FOUR: CRIMINALIZATION
Analysis of legislation from
those countries with specific
child pornography provisions
shows many similarities as well
as some differences between the
offence object and the acts covered.
Figure 4.23: Criminalization of computer‐related
production, distribution or possession of child pornography
18%
Yes, cyber‐specific offence
Yes, general offence
Yes, both
3%
No, not a criminal offence
Offence object – Most
international
and
regional
65%
instruments use the term ‘child
14%
pornography’ to define the object
of the offence. The League of
Arab States Convention uses
Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q36. (n=57)
the term ‘pornographic material
depicting a child’. Figure 4.24
shows that terminology varies at
Figure 4.24: Terminologies used in computer‐related child
pornography provisions
the national level. For 70
countries whose provisions
13%
Child Pornography
were reviewed, almost 70 per
Child abuse material
cent use the term ‘child
4%
Indecent material
pornography.’ Just over 10 per
Obsence material
7%
cent use the term ‘pornographic
Contrary to public moral
material depicting a child.’ Other
3%
Pornographic material
variants include ‘obscene material
6%
depicting a child,’ ‘child abuse
material,’ ‘material contrary to public
67%
morals involving a child,’ and
‘indecent material depicting a child.’
Source: UNODC legislation review. (n=70)
Whether differences in terms
translate into practical differences in the nature of material criminalized cannot be assessed from
legislative texts alone, as provisions are also subject to interpretation by national judicial authorities.
Legislation can, however, define the scope of media included within the offence. Some
international and regional instruments, for example, refer to ‘visual material’ and ‘texts’ that depict
child pornography. Defining included media in this way may risk, however, excluding audio material.
A number of instruments (including the ITU/CARICOM/CTU Model Legislative Texts and the
EU Directive on Child Exploitation) therefore refer to ‘any representation, by whatever means.’ The
Council
of
Europe
Cybercrime
Child pornography: National example from a country in
Convention and the Commonwealth
Western Europe
Model Law, on the other hand, refer to
A term of imprisonment of not more than __ years or a fine of
material which ‘visually depicts’ child
___ shall be imposed on any person who disseminates, offers,
pornography, thereby excluding audio
publicly displays, manufactures, imports, forwards, exports,
material. At the national level, source
acquires, or possesses an image – or a data carrier containing an
image – of a sexual act in which a person who has apparently not
legislation review shows that around
yet attained the age of eighteen is involved or appears to be
one-third of countries examined limit
involved, or who gains access to such an image by means of a
computerized device or system or through a communication
the object of criminalization to visual
service.
material or visual representation. The
remaining countries include text, audio
101
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents