CHAPTER FOUR: CRIMINALIZATION
4.3 International human rights law and criminalization
KEY RESULTS:
The increasing use of social media and user-generated internet content has resulted in regulatory
responses from government, including the use of criminal law, and calls for respect for rights to
freedom of expression
Countries report varying boundaries to expression, including with respect to defamation,
contempt, threats, incitement to hatred, insult to religious feelings, obscene material, and
undermining the state
The socio-cultural element of some limitations is reflected not only in national law, but also in
multilateral instruments. Some regional cybercrime instruments, for example, contain broad
offences regarding the violation of public morals, pornographic material, and religious or family
principles or values
International human rights law acts both as a sword and a shield, requiring criminalization of
(limited) extreme forms of expression, while protecting other forms. Some prohibitions on
freedom of expression, including incitement to genocide, hatred constituting incitement to
discrimination, hostility or violence, incitement to terrorism, and propaganda for war, are
therefore required for states that are party to relevant international human rights instruments
For other forms of expression, the ‘margin of appreciation’ allows leeway to countries in
determining the boundaries of acceptable expression in line with their own cultures and legal
traditions
Nonetheless, international human rights law will intervene at a certain point. Penal laws on
defamation, disrespect for authority, and insult, for example, that apply to online content will face
a high threshold of demonstrating that the measures are proportionate, appropriate, and the least
intrusive possible
Where content is illegal in one country, but legal to produce and disseminate in another, States
will need to focus criminal justice responses on persons accessing content within the national
jurisdiction, rather than on content produced outside of the country
International human rights law both prescribes and prohibits criminalization in the area of
cybercrime. Jurisprudence around the area of freedom of speech is particularly developed in
assisting countries to place boundaries around criminalization of expression in areas as diverse as
hate speech, incitement to terrorism, defamation, obscenity and insult.
Human rights as a ‘shield’ and ‘sword’
Over 30 years ago, the Chair of the then United Nations Committee on Crime Prevention
and Control89 stated that ‘Crime is what is defined by law as such. On the other hand, the definition must take
into account the existence of, and respect for human rights and not merely be the expression of arbitrary power.’90 In
other words, national criminal laws are not to be excluded from the oversight of international
human rights law.91
89
90
91
The Committee was established by resolution of the United Nations Economic and Social Council in May 1971. See United
Nations Economic and Social Council. Resolution 1548(L), 1971.
López-Rey, M., 1978. Crime and Human Rights. Federal Probation 43(1):10-15, p.11.
For the purposes of this Study, the human rights contained in customary international law, the nine core international human rights
treaties and their protocols, as well as the treaties of the three regional human rights mechanisms, and the authoritative
interpretations of these instruments by mechanisms established thereunder, or otherwise for the purposes of their promotion and
107
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents