With some notable exceptions (such as the obligation to make all acts of torture a criminal
offence and the prohibition of retroactive criminal offences),92 international human rights law has
not traditionally specified directly what should, or should not, be a criminal offence in national law.93
Nonetheless, international human rights law jurisprudence increasingly faces the question of
whether the criminalization of certain conduct is compatible with, or even required, by individual
human rights. In doing so, international human rights law can act both as a ‘shield’ and a ‘sword’ –
either neutralizing or triggering the criminal law.94
While the state which is party to human rights treaties has a obligation to establish criminal
law and systems sufficient to deter and respond to attacks on individuals,95 it must not go so far as
to deny individual rights by its criminalization of particular conduct.96 In undertaking this
assessment, the criminal law provision must be assessed on a ‘right-by-right’ basis,97 In order to test
whether its contents infringe a range of individual rights – such as the right not to be subjected to
arbitrary or unlawful interference with privacy, family, home or correspondence,98 the right to
freedom of thought, conscience and religion,99 or the right of peaceful assembly.100
The balancing act
Such an assessment frequently requires international human rights bodies to carefully weigh
a number of interests. Many provisions of international human rights law are not absolute. Rights to
freedom of thought, conscience, religion, expression, and association, for example, may be subject
to restrictions (including criminal law restrictions)101 that can be shown to be necessary for a range
of interests, including national security, public safety, public order, the protection of public health or
morals, or the protection of the rights and freedoms of others.102
Permissible interferences with human rights must usually be: (i) prescribed by or in
accordance with law; (ii) meet legitimate aims; (iii) and be necessary in a democratic society.103 In the
European context, in determining the question of necessity, the ECtHR considers whether the
interference is proportionate to an identified ‘pressing social need’.104 The state is granted a ‘margin of
appreciation’ in this respect.105 The margin is ‘context dependent’ ��� in particular with reference to
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
implementation, are taken as the principal expression of ‘international human rights law’. Including: ICCPR; ICESCR; ICERD;
CEDAW; CAT; CRC; ICRMW; CPED; and CRPD. In addition, Optional Protocols to ICESCR, ICCPR, CEDAW, CRC, CAT,
and CRPD cover areas such as the abolition of the death penalty (ICCPR-OP2), the involvement of children in armed conflict
(OP-CRC-AC), and the sale of children, child prostitution and child pornography (OP-CRC-SC) (also listed as a ‘cybercrime’
instrument in this Study). At the regional level, including: EHCR and its 15 Protocols, including on protection of property and the
right to education, freedom of movement, abolition of the death penalty, and a general prohibition on discrimination, the ACHR in
the Americas, and in Africa, the ACHPR. At present, there is no Asia-wide convention on human rights.
CAT, Art. 4, and ICCPR, Art. 15(1).
It should be noted however that international human rights law does require redress for violations of human rights and that this
may imply in turn the promulgation of appropriate criminal laws sufficient to deter and respond to certain violations.
Tulkens, F., 2011. The Paradoxical Relationship between Criminal Law and Human Rights. Journal of International Criminal Justice,
9(3):577-595.
See, for example, ECtHR. Application No 23452/94. 28 October 1998, in which the court stated that the right to life (ECHR,
Article 2(1)) included the obligation to put in place ‘effective criminal law provisions to deter the commission of offences against the person backed
up by law enforcement machinery for the prevention, suppression and sanctioning of breaches of such provisions.’
United Nations Commission on Narcotic Drugs, and Commission on Crime Prevention and Criminal Justice, 2010. Drug control,
crime prevention and criminal justice: A Human Rights perspective. Note by the Executive Director. E/CN.7/2010/CRP.6 –
E/CN.15/2010/CRP.1. 3 March 2010.
Ibid.
ICCPR, Art. 17.
ICCPR, Art. 18.
ICCPR, Art. 21.
The European Court of Human Rights has found that the existence of a criminal prohibition on certain conduct can be sufficient
to continuously interfere with human rights (in this case, the right to private life) even where there is a consistent policy of not
bringing criminal proceedings. See ECtHR. Application No 15070/89. 22 April 1993.
See, for example, ICCPR, Art. 21.
See, for example, the formulations used in ECHR, Arts. 8-11.
ECtHR. Application No 5493/72. 7 December 1976.
For a general review, see Legg, A., 2012. The Margin of Appreciation in International Human Rights Law. Oxford: Oxford Monographs in
International Law.
108
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents