CHAPTER FOUR: CRIMINALIZATION United Nations Special Rapporteur on the promotion and protection of the right to freedom of opinion and expression, identifies four forms of expression that are required to be prohibited by international law: child pornography;119 direct and public incitement to commit genocide;120 advocacy of national, racial or religious hatred that constitutes incitement to discrimination, hostility or violence;121 and incitement to terrorism.122 The Special Rapporteur could also have added propaganda for war.123 As discussed below, other limitations on expression enjoy less support within international human rights law. Criminalization required by international human rights law The table details a number of human rights provisions and cases, according to outcome – whether criminalization is required, acceptable, not required, or potentially incompatible with international human rights law. The table highlights that – at least under the available international jurisprudence – states may legitimately restrict freedom of speech in areas such as hate speech and obscenity. On the other hand, restrictions that are overly broad, that lack legal certainty, or that stifle pluralistic debate may be incompatible with international human rights standards. In this context, international human rights law acts as a shield – guarding against over-criminalization. Hate speech At the international level, ICCPR Article 20 provides that ‘any advocacy of national, racial or religious hatred that constitute incitement to discrimination, hostility or violence shall be prohibited by law.’124 When asked about the criminalization of computerrelated acts involving racism or xenophobia, three quarters of responding countries reported that relevant criminal offences existed. The remainder reported that such 119 120 121 122 123 124 ICCPR, Article 20(2), ICERD, Article 4, and ACHR, Article 13 Any advocacy of national, racial or religious hatred that constitutes incitement to [discrimination, hostility or violence (ICCPR)]/[lawless violence or to any other similar action (ACHR)]/[racial discrimination, or to acts of violence against any race or group of persons or another colour or origin (ICERD)] shall be [prohibited by law (ICCPR)] [considered as offences punishable by law (ACHR and ICERD)] OP-CRC-SC, Article 3 Producing, distributing, disseminating, importing, exporting, offering, selling or possessing for the above purposes child pornography shall be fully covered under criminal or penal law, whether such offences are committed domestically or transnationally or on an individual or organized basis. ICCPR, Art 20(1) and ACHR, Article 13 Any propaganda for war [shall be prohibited by law (ICCPR)]/[shall be considered as an offence punishable be law (ACHR)] Criminalization acceptable under human rights decisions ECtHR Application No 5446/03 A conviction for internet publication of material falling under an obscenity act was found not to breach the right to freedom of expression, even though the material may have been legal in the third country in which the internet site was operated and controlled. The applicant did not dispute that the material was obscene under the Act, and the Court found that the interference was proportionate, taking into account the commercial nature of the internet site. ECtHR Application No 10883/05 A conviction for incitement to national, racial, or religious discrimination resulting from statements posted by a city mayor on a municipal council website was found not to breach the right to freedom of expression. The statements called for the boycott of products from a third state. The court found the interference to be relevant and sufficient, taking into account the public office held by the applicant. Criminalization not required under human rights decisions ECtHR Application No 31358/03 The respondent country was under no obligation to investigate a complaint to the police concerning receipt of unsolicited SPAM containing pornography, where existing criminal laws did not cover such conduct. United Nations OP-CRC-SC, Art. 3. Genocide Convention, Art. 3; Rome Statute, Art. 25(3)(e); Statute of the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia, Art. 4(3)(c); Statute of the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda, Art. 2(3)(c). ICCPR, Art. 20(2). United Nations Security Council Resolution 1624 (2005), Para 1.S/RES/1624 (2005), 14 September 2005. ICCPR, Art. 20(1). It should be noted that ICCPR Article 20 does not require criminalization, merely prohibition by law. The ACHR and ICERD, on the other hand, require such advocacy to be considered as offences punishable by law. 111

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents