acts were not a crime.125
Limits of criminalization under human rights decisions
Where such acts are
criminalized, the majority of offences
were classified as ‘general,’ rather
than ‘cyber-specific.’ Approaches to
criminalization in this area show
considerable
diversity.
Some
countries have offences which cover
incitement to racial and religious
hatred, while others cover only racial
or ethnic issues.126 Positions further
range from narrow limitations only
on speech intended to ‘create fear of
future harm,’ to broad criminalization
covering ‘making insulting remarks’
about a group of persons on the
grounds of race, religion or belief,
sex, sexual orientation or disability.127
ECtHR Application No 13290/07
A criminal conviction for defamation of a public official regarding
comments posted on a website about decisions of the official was
found to be a disproportionate interference with the right to
freedom of expression. The Court held that elected officials must
have a particular tolerance regarding criticism directed at them and
the verbal excesses which may sometimes accompany this.
UN-HRC Communication CCPR/C/103/D/1815/2008
The Committee concluded that the conviction of a radio
broadcaster for defamation constituted an illegitimate restriction of
the right to freedom of expression. The Committee highlighted
that such laws should include the defence of truth and should not
be applied to expressions that could not be subject to verification.
ECtHR Application 2034/07
A criminal conviction for ‘serious insult against the King’ was
found to be a disproportionate interference with the right to
freedom of expression. The Court noted that such a sanction, by its
very nature, will inevitably have a chilling effect.
UN-HRC Communication CCPR/C/85/D/1180/2003
The Committee concluded that the applicant’s conviction for
criminal insult contained in an article about the leader of a party
group was a disproportionate interference with the right to
freedom of expression. The Committee noted that for figures in
the political domain, the value placed by the Covenant upon
uninhibited expression is particularly high.
The increasing use of social
media has resulted in a number of
recent cases involving the internet
that raise hate speech issues, ECtHR Application 27520/07
including video containing anti- A conviction for ‘denigrating the nation, the republic, the grand
national assembly, and the government of the republic or the
Islamic content and Twitter messages judicial bodies of the state’ was found to be a disproportionate
inciting racism.128 While ICCPR interference with the right to freedom of expression. The Court
Article 20 imposes an obligation to observed that the term was too wide and vague and did not enable
individuals to regulate their conduct or to foresee the consequences
combat such expression, it is of their acts.
important to recall that ICCPR ECtHR Application 35071/97
Article 20 requires a high threshold. A conviction for ‘incitement to hatred or hostility on the basis of
Restrictions must meet the three part social class, race, religion, denomination or region’ regarding
test of legality, proportionality and comments criticising democratic principles and calling for the
introduction of Sharia law was found to be a disproportionate
necessity. In assessing the severity of interference with the right to freedom of expression. The Court
the hatred – and hence the highlighted that the comments were made in the context of
pluralistic debate.
justification for restricting freedom of
expression – a threshold assessment
should include: (i) the context of the statement; (ii) the position or status of the speaker; (iii) the
intent (negligence and recklessness should not suffice); (iv) the content or form of statement; (v) the
extent of the statement; and (vi) the degree of risk of resulting harm.129 Non-binding principles
125
126
127
128
129
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q35.
United Nations Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, 2012. Rabat Plan of Action on the prohibition of advocacy of national,
racial or religious hatred that constitutes incitement to discrimination, hostility or violence. Conclusions and recommendations emanating from
the four regional expert workshops organized by OHCHR, in 2011, and adopted by experts in Rabat, Morocco on 5 October 2012.
OSCE, 2011. Freedom of Expression on the Internet: A study of legal provisions and practices related to freedom of expression, the free flow of
information and media pluralism on the Internet in OSCE participating States; and Halpin, S., 2010. Racial hate speech: A comparative
analysis of the impact of international human rights law upon the law of the United Kingdom and the United States. Marquette Law
Review, 94(2):463-497.
See, for example, http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-19606155 and http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-englandgloucestershire-20560496
United Nations Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, 2012. Rabat Plan of Action on the prohibition of advocacy of national,
racial or religious hatred that constitutes incitement to discrimination, hostility or violence. Conclusions and recommendations emanating from
the four regional expert workshops organized by OHCHR, in 2011, and adopted by experts in Rabat, Morocco on 5 October 2012.
112
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents