CHAPTER FOUR: CRIMINALIZATION
criminal law applicable to forms of online expression; and (ii) discussion concerning criminalization
differences arising from jurisdictional issues and diverse legal traditions.
Faced with a large rise in social media ‘crimes,’144 some countries have, for example, recently
issued interim guidance on prosecuting cases involving communications sent via social media.145
Such guidance emphasizes that criminal provisions must be interpreted consistently with free speech
principles and can assist in clarifying the extent of acceptable expression. In this respect, the human
rights doctrine of the ‘margin of appreciation’ allows a certain amount of leeway to countries in
determining the boundaries of acceptable expression in line with their own cultures and legal
traditions.146 Nonetheless, international human rights law will intervene at a certain point. The
United Nations Human Rights Committee has found, for example, that penal defamation laws may
breach rights to freedom of expression and should include defences such as the defence of truth.147
The Committee has also expressed concern regarding laws on matters such as lese majesty, desacato,
disrespect for authority, disrespect for flags and symbols, defamation of the head of state, and the
protection of the honour of public officials.148
When it comes to global internet content, cases such as Perrin149 and LICRA v Yahoo!150
highlight difficulties that arise where internet content that is generated and acceptable in one country
is made available in a third country. In Perrin, for example, the European Court of Human Rights
found that application of the obscenity laws of the respondent country to internet content on a site
operated and controlled in a third country where the content was not illegal, did not exceed the
respondent state’s margin of appreciation.151 Commentators have argued that, in this case, the
European Court applied an overly broad margin of appreciation and failed to sufficiently address the
jurisdictional issue – potentially sanctioning a wide jurisdictional reach for countries over content
producers in other countries, according to their own content standards.152 The Court did not, for
example, examine the closeness or otherwise of the link between the applicant, the site-owning
company based in the third country, and the respondent country.153 In this respect, the Joint
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
In England and Wales, for example, in 2008, there were 556 reports of alleged social media crimes with 46 people charged. In 2012,
there were 4,908 reports with 653 people charged. See http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-20851797 In Western Asia, a number of
recent criminal cases related to internet social media content have also been reported, see http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/worldmiddle-east-20587246
Crown Prosecution Service, 2012. Interim guidelines on prosecuting cases involving communications sent via social media. Issued by the Director
of Public Prosecutions, 19 December 2012.
Where a particularly important right or value is at stake, the margin of appreciation accorded to a state will, in general, be restricted
(ECtHR. Application No 44362/04. 18 April 2006). In contrast, if the aim pursued does not enjoy universal consensus – such as
the meaning of the ‘protection of morals’ – the margin of appreciation will be wide (ECtHR. Application No 10737/84. 24 May
1988). The ECtHR employs, amongst others, a common (European) consensus test in determining the margin available – when
consensus on the meaning or need for limitations on particular rights is absent, the margin expands. Conversely, when consensus is
present, it is taken to mean that the ‘core’ meaning of the right is narrowly defined and the margin to deviate contracts. The
domestic margin of appreciation thus goes hand in hand with a ‘European supervision’ – concerning both the aim of interferences
and their ‘necessity’. The margin of appreciation doctrine is less developed in the work of the Inter-American Court of Human
Rights and the United Nations Human Rights Committee. Nonetheless, commentators note that there is an increasing role for the
margin of appreciation in the Inter-American system, and that ample evidence supports the proposition that the doctrine forms
part of the United Nations Human Rights Committee’s practice (Legg, A., 2012. The Margin of Appreciation in International Human
Rights Law. Oxford: Oxford Monographs in International Law).
See United Nations Human Rights Committee Communication CCPR/C/85/D/1180/2003 and United Nations Human Rights
Committee, 2011. General Comment No. 34. Article 19: Freedoms of opinion and expression. CCPR/C/GC/34, 12 September 2011.
para. 47.
Ibid. para. 38.
ECtHR Application No. 5446/04.
In Licra v Yahoo!, a national court ordered Yahoo! Inc. to take measures to prevent users in that country from accessing an auction
web site based in a third country selling Nazi memorabilia (Ordonnance de référérendue le 20 Novembre 2000. Tribunal de grande
Instance de Paris. No. RG : 00/05308). In subsequent proceedings in the site-hosting country, a national court held on appeal that
there were no grounds for jurisdiction unless or until the foreign court judgement was brought for enforcement in the national
courts, and that a freedom of expression argument could not therefore be entertained at that time (Yahoo Inc. v La Ligue Contre le
Racisme et l’Antisemitisme. No. 01-17424. United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit.)
ECtHR Application No. 5446/04.
Council of Europe, Commissioner for Human Rights, 2012. Social Media and Human Rights. Issue Discussion Paper. CommDH, 8
February 2012.
Ibid. p.17.
115
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents