Declaration of the International Mechanisms for
Promoting Freedom of Expression on Freedom of
Expression and the Internet recommends that
jurisdiction in legal cases relating to internet
content should be restricted to ‘States to which those
cases have a real and substantial connection.’ This would
be ‘normally because the author is established there, the
content is uploaded there and/or the content is specifically
directed at that State.’154
‘Prosecutors should have regard to the fact that the
context in which interactive social media dialogue
takes place is quite different to the context in which
other communications take place…
Communications intended for a few may reach
millions. Against that background, prosecutors
should only proceed with cases… where they are
satisfied that the communication in question is more
than: offensive, shocking or disturbing; or satirical,
iconoclastic or rude comment; or the expression of
unpopular or unfashionable opinion about serious or
trivial matters, or banter or humour, even if
distasteful to some or painful to those subjected to it.’
Overall, diverse national approaches to the
criminalization of internet and social media content
can be accommodated by international human
rights law, within certain boundaries. These include
Guidelines on prosecuting cases involving
communications sent via social media (a country
permissible criminal prohibitions on child
in Northern Europe)
pornography; direct and public incitement to
commit genocide; advocacy of national, racial or
religious hatred that constitutes incitement to discrimination, hostility or violence; incitement to
terrorism; and propaganda for war. Criminal offences relating to defamation, obscene material, and
insult, however, will likely face a high threshold – even within the margin of appreciation – of
demonstrating that the measures conform to the principle of proportionality, are appropriate to
achieve their protective function, and are the least intrusive instrument amongst those which might
achieve protection.155
Moreover, where states attempt to assert jurisdiction over internet content based on their
own national standards, it is likely that international law will increasingly crystallize a need to
demonstrate that content created or hosted in other countries is specifically targeted to, or
frequently accessed by, persons within the enforcing state. Where content is illegal in one country,
but legal to produce and disseminate in another, international human rights law offers an important
tool – both as a sword and a shield – in helping to delineate acceptable expression. As international
and regional human rights systems develop their jurisprudence, it is possible that, at least in some
areas, a human rights ‘consensus’ can guide the size of the margin of appreciation at the
international level. Where national differences ultimately cannot be reconciled, states will likely need
to focus criminal justice responses on persons accessing content within their national jurisdiction,
rather than on content producers outside of the national jurisdiction.
154
155
United Nations Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Opinion and Expression, the OSCE Representative on Freedom of the Media,
the OAS Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Expression, and the ACHPR Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Expression and
Access to Information. Joint Declaration on Freedom of Expression and the Internet. Available at:
http://www.osce.org/fom/78309
United Nations Human Rights Committee, 2011. General Comment No. 34. Article 19: Freedoms of opinion and expression.
CCPR/C/GC/34, 12 September 2011. para. 34.
116
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents