CHAPTER FIVE: LAW ENFORCEMENT AND INVESTIGATIONS
present particular challenges to traditional powers. Many responding countries reported that
investigative powers are frequently ‘out of step with new and emerging technologies’ and often ‘legislation [is]
designed for physical search and search, and therefore the law’s instructions…don’t feed the needs, interests and
constitutional procedures relevant for cybercrime investigations.’30
Legal frameworks for the investigation of cybercrime – whether predominantly ‘general’ or
‘cyber-specific’ laws – thus require both: (i) a clear scope of application of the power, in order to
guarantee legal certainty in its use; and (ii) sufficient legal authority for actions such as ensuring
preservation of computer data, and the collection of stored and real-time data. In this respect,
specialized procedural frameworks offer the possibility to clearly define relevant concepts – such as
‘computer data’ in the first place, as well as data ‘at rest’ and data ‘in transit.’31 They also allow
differentiation between types of data, such as ‘subscriber’ data (the basic registration details of
computer service users, such as name and address), ‘traffic’ data (data indicating the origin,
destination, route, time, date, size, duration, or type of a communication made by means of a
computer system), and ‘content’ data (the actual content of a communication).32
During information gathering for the Study, countries were asked about the existence of
either general or cyber-specific legal powers for 10 different actions relevant to law enforcement
investigations into cybercrime (and other crimes involving electronic evidence). The investigative
actions asked about were: (i) law enforcement search for computer hardware or data; (ii) seizure of
computer hardware or data; (iii) order to a person for supply to law enforcement of subscriber
information; (iv) order to a person for supply of stored traffic data; (v) order to a person for supply
for stored content data; (vi) real time collection of traffic data; (vii) real-time collection of content
data; (viii) order to a
Figure 5.3: National approaches to investigative measures for cybercrime
person to preserve and
maintain the integrity of
Search
computer data under
Seizure
their control for a
specified period of time
Order for subscriber
data
(‘expedited
Cyber‐specific power
Order for traffic data
preservation’ of data);
General power
(ix) use of remote
Order for content data
Both
computer
forensics
Real‐time traffic data
No power
tools; and (x) direct law
Real‐time content data
enforcement access to
extraterritorial
Expedited preservation
computer data (‘transRemote forensics
border’
access
to
33
computer data).
Trans‐border access
Figure
5.3
Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q42‐51. (n=55)
provides
a
broad
overview of the existence of legal provisions covering the ten investigative actions, as reported by
over 50 country responses to the Study questionnaire. Responses demonstrate that the majority of
30
31
32
33
Networks 2013, pp.45-71.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q53.
Walden, I., 2003. Addressing the Data Problem. Information Security Technical Report, 8(2); Nieman, A., 2009. Cyberforensics: Bridging
the Law/Technology Divide. JILT, 2009(1).
Sieber, U., 2008. Mastering complexity in the global cyberspace: The harmonization of computer-related criminal law. In: DelmasMarty, M., Pieth, M., Sieber, U. (eds.). Les chemins de l’HarmonisationPénale/Harmonising Criminal Law. Collection de L’UMR de Droit
Comparé de Paris. Paris: Société de législation comparée.
See Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q42-51.
123
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents