CHAPTER FIVE: LAW ENFORCEMENT AND INVESTIGATIONS
anything… [even though] the Act does not provide specifically for cybercrime.’35 Some countries also reported
that it was good practice for powers of investigation relating to computers and other devices to
‘extend to all crimes and not just traditional computer crimes’ and that relevant procedural laws should be
both ‘comprehensive’ and ‘precise.’36
Comprehensive investigative powers for
Overall, three main approaches were
cybercrime: National example from a country
apparent from country responses to the Study
in Southern Europe
questionnaire: Some countries have no specific laws
Seizure of computer data
for cybercrime investigations and apply traditional
Seizure of computer data, depending on what is
procedural powers as far as possible under a broad
deemed to be most appropriate or proportional,
interpretation. Other countries have amended
taking into account the interests of the case, may
general investigatory powers in respect of some
take the following forms:
a) Seizing the computer system support
specific issues and, through use of general and
equipment or the computer-data storage
cyber-specific powers, are able to apply a range of
medium, as well as devices required to read
measures such as orders for data, search and seizure
data;
of data, and preservation of data. Finally, some
b) Making a copy of those computer data, in an
autonomous means of support, which shall be
countries have introduced a comprehensive range of
attached to the file;
new investigative powers specifically designed for
c) Maintaining by technological means the
obtaining electronic evidence. Legislative provisions
integrity of data, without copying or removing
in one country in Southern Europe, for example,
them; or
specify four different ways in which data may be
d) Removing the computer data or blocking
access thereto.
considered ‘seized’ – (i) seizing the medium itself; (ii)
making a copy; (iii) maintaining the integrity of data
without removal or copying; and (iv) removing the data or blocking access to the data. Such
provisions assist in removing legal uncertainty surrounding the application of ‘traditional’
investigative powers.
Examination of the relationship between existence of specialized legislative powers, and the
perceived sufficiency of cybercrime investigation frameworks, shows some degree of
correspondence for countries that responded to the questionnaire. For those countries that reported
investigative frameworks to be ‘sufficient’ or sufficient ‘in part’, around 40 per cent of all
investigative actions asked about were covered by cyber-specific powers. In contrast, for those
countries that reported investigative frameworks to be ‘insufficient’, only 20 per cent of all
investigative actions were covered by cyber-specific powers.37 This finding highlights the importance
of the development of specialized investigative powers – at a minimum, for measures where the
extension of traditional powers is in doubt. Chapter Seven (International cooperation) of this Study
highlights that the global nature of cybercrime means that a lack of investigative powers in one
country can have an impact on other countries where they request international cooperation in the
gathering of extraterritorial evidence.
As discussed in Chapter Three (Legislation and frameworks), a number of international and
regional instruments provide for comprehensive investigative power frameworks.38 The table in
Annex Three summarizes the powers, by article, in a number of these frameworks. The next section
of this Chapter continues to examine, in detail, the nature of investigative power provisions, both as
found in multilateral instruments and as reported at the national level through the Study
questionnaire. It does so for the powers of: (i) search and seizure; (ii) preservation of computer data;
35
36
37
38
Ibid.
Ibid.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q42-51 and Q53.
See Chapter Three (Legislation and frameworks), Section 3.1 Introduction – The role of law, Relevant categories of law.
125
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents