(iii) orders for computer data; (iv) real-time collection of computer data; (v) use of remote forensic
tools; and (vi) direct law enforcement access to extra-territorial data.
Search and seizure
Search and seizure warrant: National example from a country in the
As noted above,
Americas
countries may face a
(2) A warrant issued under this section may authorize a police officer to:
range of challenges to the
(a) seize any computer, data, programme, information, document or thing if he
extension of ‘traditional’
reasonably believes that it is evidence that an offence under this Act has been or
search and seizure powers
is about to be committed;
39
(b)
inspect and check the operation of any computer referred to in paragraph (a);
to intangible data. For
(c) use or cause to be used any computer referred to in paragraph (a) to search any
this
reason,
seven
programme or data held in or available to such computer;
international or regional
(d) have access to any information, code or technology which has the capability of
transforming or converting an encrypted programme or data held in or available
cybercrime instruments40
to the computer into readable and comprehensible format or text, for the
contain provisions with
purpose of investigating any offence under this Act;
specific powers to search,
(e) convert an encrypted programme or data held in another computer system at
or
similarly
access,
the place specified in the warrant, where there are reasonable grounds for
believing that computer data connected with the commission of the offence may
computer systems or
be stored in that other system;
computer-data
storage
(f) make and retain a copy of any programme or data held in the computer referred
media. Six of these
to in paragraph (a) or (e) and any other programme or data held in the
instruments also provide
computers.
for an extension of the
search
to
another
computer system within the territory of the country, if it is discovered that the information sought
after is not in the original system or media searched.41 A number of multilateral instruments also
clarify ways in which computer data can be ‘seized.’ The Commonwealth Model Law, for example,
states that the term ‘seized’ includes ‘taking a printout of output of computer data.’
At the national level,
responses
to
the
Study
questionnaire showed that search
and
seizure
of
computer
hardware or data are authorized
by general criminal procedure laws
for the majority of countries
(around 50 per cent), rather than
by cyber-specific powers.42 As
regards the application of general
search powers, one country in
Eastern Asia clarified that
traditional provisions on searches
could also be applied to ‘computer
39
40
41
42
Figure 5.5: Search and seizure instruments used in cybercrime
investigations
Search
(n=54)
Cyber‐specific powers
General powers
Both
Neither
Seizure
(n=56)
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
Source: Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q42 and Q43. (n=54, 56)
See, for instance, Brenner, S. W., Frederiksen, B.A., 2002. Computer Searches and Seizures: Some Unresolved Issues. Mich.
Telecomm. Tech. L. Rev. 39(8); Kerr, O.S., 2005. Search Warrants in an Era of Digital Evidence. Mississippi Law Journal, 75:85.
Draft African Union Convention, Arts. 3-50, 3-51; COMESA Draft Model Bill, Arts. 37, 33; Commonwealth Model Law, Arts.12,
14; Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention, Art. 19; ECOWAS Draft Directive, Art. 33; ITU/CARICOM/CTU Model
Legislative Texts, Art. 20; League of Arab States Convention, Arts. 26, 27.
Draft African Union Convention; COMESA Draft Model Bill; Commonwealth Model Law; Council of Europe Cybercrime
Convention; ITU/CARICOM/CTU Model Legislative Texts; League of Arab States Convention.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q42 and Q43.
126
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents