CHAPTER FIVE: LAW ENFORCEMENT AND INVESTIGATIONS
privacy and investigations in this Chapter examines further possible safeguards that can be required
by international human rights law. In this respect, one international instrument, the Council of
Europe Cybercrime Convention explicitly refers to interception of content data in relation ‘to a range
of serious offences to be determined by domestic law.’59 From a practical perspective, multilateral instruments
often envisage that real-time collection of data can be carried out either directly by law enforcement
authorities through the application of their own technical means, or by compelling a service
provider, within its existing technical capability, to collect or record computer data, or to co-operate
and assist authorities to do so.
At the national level, around 40 per cent of responding countries reported that a general
investigative power was used to authorize real-time interception of traffic and content data. A
number of countries referred, for example, to the extension of general ‘Telecommunications
intercept
acts’
or
‘Eavesdropping laws’ to the
Real-time collection of data: National example from a country in
real-time
collection
of
Western Asia
computer data.60 Overall,
Real-time collection of traffic data
more than 60 per cent of
1. If there is a probable cause that a person commits a crime though a
computer system, a prosecutor is authorized to file a motion with a court
responding countries reported
having jurisdiction over the investigation place, to issue an order
the existence of a legal power
requesting real-time collection of traffic data, thereby a service provider is
obliged to cooperate with and assist an investigative body in real-time
for real-time collection of
collection or recording of traffic data which are associated with specified
data – either through a
communications made and transmitted by means of a computer system
general or cyber-specific
within the territory...
2. Motions provided by paragraph 1 of the present Article shall consider
power.
Some countries
technical capability for real-time collection and recording of traffic data of
highlighted the application of
the service provider. The term for real time collection and recording of
traffic data shall not exceed the term necessary for collecting evidence in
safeguards to such powers,
criminal case.
including the limitation of
3. Motions provided by paragraph 1 and 2 of this Article, shall be
real-time collection of content
considered by the court in accordance with the procedure established by
Article <…> of the present Code.
data only to serious crimes.61
As
regards
the
practicalities
of
data
interception, a distinction is often made between private and public service providers. National
legislation in one country in Western Europe, for example, specifies that interception of computer
data carried by public providers shall be intercepted with the cooperation of the service provider,
unless such cooperation is not possible or is contrary to the interests of the investigation. For nonpublic service providers, the national legislation providers that the service provider will be ‘offered’ the
opportunity to cooperate in the interception, unless this is impossible or undesirable.62
Remote forensic tools
A range of technological tools offer possibilities to law enforcement agencies both for the
direct remote collection of evidence from computer systems, and for the collection of intelligence or
investigation-related information more generally. Tools such as key-loggers and remoteadministration software, when placed on the device of a suspect, can remotely supply information
58
59
60
61
62
See Walden, I. Addressing the Data Problem: The Legal Framework Governing Forensics in an Online Environment. Second
International Conference iTrust 2004, Proceedings. Oxford, 29 March-1 April 2004.
Council of Europe Cybercrime Convention, Art. 20.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q47 and Q48.
Ibid.
Koops, B-J. 2010. Cybercrime legislation. Electronic Journal of Comparative Law, 14(3).
131
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents