The range of privacy and safeguard approaches reported by countries through the Study
questionnaire – and, indeed, the range of situations brought before international human rights
tribunals – demonstrates a considerable diversity in privacy protection during law enforcement
investigations. Examination of relevant national privacy decisions further highlights this point.
National decisions on the procedure for law enforcement access to ISP subscriber information, for
example, range from those which hold that police requests to ISPs for subscriber information without
judicial authorization are compatible with customer privacy expectations, to those which hold that
proper judicial process is required by privacy rights. 101
As with a human rights assessment of criminalization, international human rights law is, to
some extent, able to accommodate such differences through doctrine such as the margin of
appreciation.102 Nonetheless, it is clear that divergent national privacy approaches will become an
increasing challenge in the context of trans-national law enforcement investigations and
developments such as cloud computing.
Privacy, jurisdiction and the cloud
Cloud data processing involves multiple data locales or data centres, distributed across
different national jurisdictions, and with different private data controllers and processors.103 Under
present conditions, although data location may be technically knowable, cloud computing users are
not always informed exactly ‘where’ their data is held. In turn, jurisdictional approaches both to the
data protection regime governing data held by cloud service providers, and criminal procedure law
governing national law enforcement investigations are complex.104
This introduces a high degree of uncertainty for users concerning the privacy regime that
will apply to their data and the circumstances under which privacy may be infringed for the purposes
of law enforcement investigations or security surveillance. Legislation in some countries, for
example, contains extensive surveillance powers that could apply, without judicial authorization, to
the data of non-nationals which is ‘at rest’ in cloud servers located within the national jurisdiction.105
Where national privacy guarantees differentiate between nationals and non-nationals,106 users may
have (i) no knowledge of such actions; and (ii) no legal recourse, either under the law of the state
applying such investigative measures, or – depending upon the jurisdictional application of their
home laws (and the legal incorporation structure of the cloud service provider) – within their own
countries.
Divergences in privacy law jurisdiction are suggested by country responses to the Study
questionnaire. Responding countries reported a range of legal positions regarding the extra-territorial
application of national privacy protections. A few countries noted that privacy protections do have
extra-territorial effect, including under conditions such as where the act or practice falling outside of
the territory nonetheless has an ‘organisational link’ with the country. Other countries confirmed that
national privacy laws do not apply to computer data or electronic communications, either in realtime or stored outside of the territory. One country stated that it was an ‘open question, whether computer
material located abroad would enjoy the same [privacy] protection as computer material located in a server [within the
101
102
103
104
105
106
Convention only in so far as strictly necessary for safeguarding the democratic institutions.’ ECtHR Application No. 28341/95.
See for example, R v Ward, 2012 ONCA 660 and State v. Reid, 194 N.J. 376 (2008).
Legg, A., 2012. The Margin of Appreciation in International Human Rights Law. Oxford: Oxford Monographs in International Law.
On the concepts of data ‘controllers’ and ‘processors’, see Directive 95/46/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of
24 October 1995 on the protection of individuals with regard to the processing of personal data and on the free movement of such
data (as amended by Regulation (EC) No. 1882/2003 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 29 September 2003).
See, for example European Parliament Directorate General for Internal Polices, Citizens’ Rights and Constitutional Affairs. 2012.
Fighting cybercrime and protecting privacy in the cloud.
Ibid.
See for example, Verdugo-Urquidez 494 U.S. 259 (1990) and USFISCR No. 08-01.
140
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents