CHAPTER FIVE: LAW ENFORCEMENT AND INVESTIGATIONS
territory].’ 107 The majority of responding countries were nonetheless clear that national privacy
protections would apply to investigative actions carried out within the territory at the request of
foreign law enforcement. One country noted, for example that ‘when a request for mutual legal assistance
by a foreign country intrudes upon the domestic law which protects privacy, such request can be set aside.’ 108
Recent work by the European Parliament finds that ‘in the field of cybercrime, the challenge of
privacy in a cloud context is underestimated, if not ignored.’ 109 While countries may have developed a range
of privacy safeguards for law enforcement action within a national context, these are diverse and
may not be easily reconciled in trans-national cybercrime investigation situations – potentially
leading to conflicts of laws or jurisdictional gaps. As countries work to promulgate laws that address
the delicate balance between individual privacy and the prevention and control of crime, it is critical
that national laws reflect common rule of law and human rights principles for law enforcement
investigative actions.
One strong starting point can be found in the human rights jurisprudence discussed above
and summarized in the box below – which sets out clear rule of law principles for surveillance laws.
Even such principles, however, have yet to grapple with the challenging questions of cross-territorial
data transfers. In this respect, while harmonization of privacy standards will help to increase the
predictability of law enforcement access to user data, including by foreign authorities, countries will
also increasingly need to address the jurisdictional reach of national privacy protections. This may
entail both: (i) ensuring that support to foreign law enforcement investigations is fully subject to
national privacy standards; and (ii) that causes of action are available to persons outside of national
jurisdictions that are affected by the actions of the law enforcement authorities of that country.
Rule of law principles for surveillance laws
•
•
•
•
Law must be sufficiently clear to give an adequate indication of conditions and circumstances in which
authorities are empowered to use an investigative measure, including:
o The nature of the offences which may give rise to use of the measure
o A definition of the categories of people liable to the measure
o A limit on the duration of the measure
o The procedure to be followed for examining, using and storing the data obtained
o Precautions to be taken when communicating the data to other parties
o The circumstances in which data obtained may or must be erased or destroyed
Adequate and effective guarantees must exist against abuse, taking into account:
o The nature, scope and duration of the possible measures
o The grounds required for ordering them
o The authorities competent to permit, carry out and supervise them
o Remedies provided in national law
Laws should provide for review or oversight of implementation of measures by a body or official that is
either external to the services deploying the measure or having certain qualifications ensuring its
independence
Laws should provide that as soon as notification can be made without jeopardising the purpose of the
measure after its termination, information should be provided to the persons concerned
ECtHR Application No. 62540/00
107
108
109
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q21.
Ibid.
European Parliament Directorate General for Internal Policies, Citizens’ Rights and Constitutional Affairs. 2012. Fighting cybercrime
and protecting privacy in the cloud.
141
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents