CHAPTER FIVE: LAW ENFORCEMENT AND INVESTIGATIONS
may be indicative of expedited preservation of data in practice through informal working
relationships between law enforcement and service providers.
Country responses regarding the most commonly used investigative powers also highlighted the
importance of search and seizure, as well as the use of orders to obtain subscriber data from service
providers. As more and more devices become connected to the internet, computer data that may
previously have been stored only on a local computer device is increasingly processed by private
sector service providers, including in cloud services. The importance for law enforcement officers of
obtaining electronic evidence from service providers is reflected in the fact that orders for subscriber
information are reported to be the most commonly used investigative measure. The section below
on investigations and the private sector examines law enforcement and service provider interactions
in detail.
Investigative challenges and good practice
Responding countries identified a number of challenges and good practices related to the
use of investigative measures and cybercrime investigations in general. Good practices reported by
countries frequently highlighted the importance of careful organization and ordering of
investigations. One country, for example, reported that ‘Preservation of data, and seizure of stored data and
computer data in a forensically sound manner is a baseline for successful cybercrime investigations.’113 Another
stated that ‘All actions should be recorded and leave an auditable trail. Each action, URL, e-mail address, etc.,
should be timed and dated, information sources and contacts recorded.’114 In addition, a number of countries
noted that the starting point for successful investigations is frequently information such as an IP
address. As a result, it was considered good practice to focus on ensuring the capability for timely
obtaining of subscriber information.115
With respect to investigative challenges encountered, many responding countries opened
their remarks on law enforcement cybercrime investigations by highlighting an increasing level of
criminal sophistication, and the need for law enforcement investigations to ‘keep up’ with
cybercrime perpetrators. One country from Europe, for example, noted that ‘attacks are becoming more
and more advanced, more and more difficult to detect, and at the same time the techniques quickly find their way to a
broader audience… we’ve also seen that digital components (as means, crime scene or target) become of more and more
importance in basically every crime.’116 Another country emphasized that ‘increases in the incidence of cybercrime
offences are being driven by the advancement of technical and programmatic tools available to attackers underpinned by
an illicit market for the commercialization of tools for committing cybercrime.’117
Increasing levels of sophistication bring increased challenges in areas such as locating
electronic evidence; use of obfuscation techniques by perpetrators; challenges with large volumes of
data for analysis; and challenges with obtaining data from service providers. At a basic investigative
level, for example, digital storage and connectivity are increasingly integrated into common
household and personal items, such as pens, cameras, watches with flash storage and USB jewellery
flash drives. In addition, wireless storage devices may be hidden in wall cavities, ceilings and floor
spaces. As noted by one country, such physical (and electronic) ‘ease of concealment’ of computer data
can present difficulties for investigations.118 Countries also highlighted problems of ‘deletion of data
storage devices.’ Where perpetrators use online communication services, such as VOIP, computer data
113
114
115
116
117
118
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q99.
Ibid.
Ibid.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q85.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q84.
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q87-96.
143
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents