may flow directly from user to user (and not through service provider servers),119 meaning that only
local copies of certain data are available – and vulnerable to subsequent deletion. In addition,
perpetrators may make use of ‘dead-dropping’ of messages in draft folders of webmail accounts
(allowing communication without a ‘sent’ email), combined with use of free public Wifi access
points, or pre-paid mobile and credit cards. One country, for example, highlighted challenges in
‘pinpointing location’ due to ‘availability of numerous free access points.’120 Many countries also reported the
use of encryption and obfuscation techniques by perpetrators. This area is address in detail in
Chapter Six (Electronic evidence and criminal justice).
Finally, many countries noted that significant challenges were faced in obtaining
information from service providers. One country in the Americas, for example, reported that the
supply of subscriber information by internet service providers on a voluntary basis led to
inconsistent practice across the country.121 Other countries reported that service providers did not
store computer data for ‘long enough’, and that it ‘takes too much time for the subscriber to provide the data to
the police.’122 A country in Asia further reported the challenge of ‘inaccurate registration details’ stored by
service providers.123 The interactions – both formal and informal – between law enforcement and
service providers are examined in the next section of this Chapter.
5.5 Investigations and the private sector
KEY RESULTS:
The interplay between law enforcement and internet service providers is particularly
complex. Service providers can hold subscriber information, billing invoices, some
connection logs, location information, and communication content
National legal obligations and private sector data retention and disclosure polices vary
widely by country, industry and type of data. Some countries report challenges in
obtaining data from service providers
Service providers most commonly report requiring due legal process for disclosure of
customer data. Accordingly, countries most often report using court orders to obtain
electronic evidence from service providers
In some cases, however, law enforcement may be able to obtain data directly. This can
be facilitated by informal partnerships between law enforcement authorities and service
providers
Obtaining data from service providers
Country and private sector responses to the Study questionnaire represent a mixed and
complex picture concerning interactions between law enforcement and the private sector. This
picture is characterized by: (i) differences between countries in legal powers to order release of
computer data by service providers; (ii) challenges where service providers are located
extraterritorially; and (iii) differences in private sector policies and degrees of formal and informal
cooperation with law enforcement authorities.
119
120
121
122
123
See, for example, http://blogs.skype.com/en/2012/07/what_does_skypes_architecture_do.html
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q87-96
Ibid.
Ibid.
Ibid.
144
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents