A number of countries
Figure 5.17: Practical and legal procedures to obtain information and evidence
from service providers
reported that multiple means of
Court Order Prosecution Police
Multiple
Other No means
obtaining data were available,
depending upon a number of
factors, including the stage of
Subscriber data
investigation or proceedings, and
Traffic data (stored)
the urgency of the request. One
Traffic data (real time)
country in Western Asia, for
Content data (stored)
Content data (real time)
example reported that stored
content data could be obtained
from a service provider ‘Based on
the order of the public prosecutor during
the process of investigation… or on the
order of the court during the trial
process.’129 Another country noted
Source: Cybercrime study questionnaire. Q102. (n=58)
that subscriber data could be
obtained on the basis of a
‘Prosecutor order, or in case of emergency, a police letter with formal agreement of the prosecutor.’130 ‘Other’ means
for obtaining data were also referred to. One country, for example, highlighted simplified means of
obtaining subscriber data, through ‘accessing the Integrated Public Number Database which is a database of
subscriber information managed by a large carrier pursuant to legislation.’131 Overall, responses showed
significant diversity in means employed by States, including police requests, ‘formal’ requests, legal
notices, warrants, judicial orders, and subpoenas.
Obtaining data from service providers: National example from a country in the Americas
Federal legislation from one country in the Americas provides that a government entity may require the disclosure by a
provider of an electronic communication service of the contents of a wire or electronic communication that is in
electronic storage in an electronic communications system for one hundred and eight days or less, only pursuant to a
warrant. Under this legislation, domestic law enforcement may obtain access to some types of data through a subpoena
(issued usually by a prosecutor), but require a court-issued warrant in order to obtain other forms of data.
Authorization
procedure
Email communication
In remote storage, opened
In remote storage, unopened and stored for more
than 180 days
In transit
In storage on home computer
In remote storage, unopened and stored for 180
days or less
Subpoena
Warrant
The national legislation also contains provisions compelling an ISP to disclose customer communications in ‘exigent
circumstances.’ Several national laws also permit the disclosure of communications content and non-content to a
governmental entity, if the provider, in good faith believes that an emergency involving danger of death or serious
physical injury to any person requires disclosure without delay of communications relating to the emergency.
Law enforcement officials may also issue a letter to a service provider to order preservation of records and other evidence
in its possession pending the issuance of a court order or other process for up to 90 days. Non-compliance with such an
order is generally confined to civil remedies and fines against the company.
129
130
131
Study cybercrime questionnaire. Q102.
Ibid.
Ibid.
146
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents